Kingdom Hearts II Who seems as though they have a heart the most?

Tch....

How'd I know Axel would come in first? *rolls eyes*

Anyways, I picked Demyx, but I think that Namine might've, too.

Roxas and Axel came across as kinda cold-hearted and uncaring for others and these were two that I feel really might've shown pity for "teh enemy".

I don't fel much like debating right now, so just take that half-arse't attempt at a post, and run wid it. =.=;

Also, whut mah debate buddeh said. XD

 

Roxas definetly has a heart, and when ever Axel's around him, Axel has a heart too, so yeah... Roxas and Axel.

 

I would say Axel because he was the only one that mentioned having feelings.

 

actually wonder why Xemnas is in there he has no feelings whatsoever
also CtR is right Demyx feels fear and anger o.o

 

I think Roxas, Dont Ask me why.

 

Both Axel and Roxas. They both had a strong feelings for each other (Wether it was just friendship or Yaoi). They showed real emotions at times.

 

I don't know why, but Xemnas just seems to have somthing there.

 

Oh, I just wrote up a thread Detailing how much I think Roxas has one.

 

Axel. He has the most personality, and is such a double-agent I'd hate to be his girlfriend...

But he shows friendship to Roxas and helps Sora even though he's a bad guy, even though we don't really know who's side they're on.

 

Axel is cruel, he killed off like at least two ( I think) of the organaztion, that it's plain to see, he dosn't have a heart, Vexen ( I think) then theres Zexion ( The coolest). I hate Axel when I think about, that's what he gets, and who cares, all he is is a nobody.

 

Axel all the way

One word - Roxas

another word - friendship

 

......................................


D:

That was not very nice... you could have worded it differently....

You have to be the single person in the entire KH gaming world that hates Axel. Honestly.

=S

 

Ok I know a lot bout kh and axel

so here i am in axels deffenise

diz made roxas, axel's only friend in the org, lose all his memorys and he may never get them back, and he may die

so axel got mad

he tried to kill everyone in the org.

he sucessed

he found roxas

roxas didn't remember

axel got mad and sad (then bought glad ware haha)

axel killed himself because his only friend didn't remember him

friendship = love (like not like like love, just love like i'd die for you, family love)

 

Actually, I really don't see any members in the Org as having Hearts at all other than Roxas who probably had a 'part' of one. I do, however, think they all were reacting in ways that would show how they would act in the 'past' with their former whole selves. It's basically off of instinct and 'memory' of having a Heart. Demyx's fear was cast aside immediately after Sora said 'you have no Heart' and well, it's true. He 'did' have a Heart but no longer possessed one. The instinct to react out of fear was just that, something he did prior and felt, but now was just a behavioral deal.

Larxene and others laughing, pouting etc are all displays of how they would show the emotions if they still had them. This includes Axel, who even Xemnas said he wants his heart badly and would do whatever to get it, or something along those lines.

Also, Axel was 'cruel' in CoM but no more dastardly truly than Vexen and Marluxia who were out to betray the Org and try gambles to take over. They both were dangers to the rest of the Org and trying to use Sora and Riku to get over on one another and the others who were not sided with them. Axel did nothing more than -survive- just as some of the others like Zexion and Lexaeus at that point were trying to do but failed. The Org members could not even trust themselves and because others were two-faced, Axel became more of a wild card and did what he did to get out of the mess and also he -was- still working for the higher Organization ideal, whereas others forsook that in personal gain. One other point to make on Axel...he was 'ordered' to kill Vexen and then went after Marluxia to 'kill the traitor'. Since both were traitors, he went after them. Also Vexen was going to narc about Roxas so he had to go. Axel in KH2 was told to go after Roxas and if he did not come back to -kill him-. When he fought Roxas the second time he found he could not kill him so he revolted against the Organization after feigning his death. Realizing he could not go back because he might be 'turned into a Dusk' is the reason Axel was a 'traitor' to the Org.

Really, the only one I can equate a Heart at all to is Roxas. I think all of the Organization were 'empathic' in a way and Saix said some key points that they know what it was like to have a heart and know how to hurt it. Axel was perhaps the most 'empathic' earnestly out of all of the Organization, which is also probably why he was able to be so intellectual at points and move around to get away with what he did. He wanted a Heart very badly and so he tried to act as though he -did- have a heart still, to not forget what it was like. Roxas, I think, was felt to be different and so Axel liked him. He was the only one Axel could trust was 'authentic' in feelings and motives, even if he disagreed with Roxas at times. So in other words, he was the only person acting 'real' and not faking things as the other Nobodies, including Axel could do easily. Axel to me was definitely a candidate for someone who should 'earn' a Heart, but I don't see he actually had one there.

Roxas however, is the only one who did not just 'react' as other Nobodies did to each thing and was not as overdramatic or under dramatic when expressing how he 'felt'. He frowned when alone, he was angry and furious at points such as facing Riku or when he busted up the computer. Those were genuine feelings. So it is he who I think had the Heart, or at least a partial one.