Birth by Sleep Who is Xehanort's apprentice?

Why would Aqua be fighting Aqua?

She couldn't be him.

 

One thing I just realized that disproves the whole "Aqua is Master Xehanorts apprentice" theory is, her and his apprentice have different Keyblades.

 

Do you mean Ansem the Wise? I don't think so.
According to his background, it doesn't say anywhere that he was with another keyblade master in the years before KH.

Please, if your going to spam, then get out of here. This is for discussion on the Upcoming Games only. Thanks.

 

Xemnas is a nobody, therefore he cannot be the apprentice. Ansem the heartless may be possible on the basis of the condition that the six apprentices discover the Heartless in the course of the story, instead of after.

 

I say Master Xehanort's apprentice is the corrupted twin brother of Terra A.K.A. Ansem's "Xehanort".

 

These theories are both the most popular.

 

Well those seem to be the most likely theories. I HIGHLY doubt Terra would go "bad".

 

He will go bad,just not that bad,i think.

He will use the power of Darkness i think,and might also become a bad guy,but not that bad and also not for long.

 

And he also said on the first trailer:
"This power i use,i use for my friends!"

 

I still belive it to be the Xehanort who appeared in KH2 and he took Xehanorts name after he was beaten.

 

Me too,i wonder what happened to his MX if that's the case.

 

hmm.....
After BBS Ansem finds MX apprentice and saves him from death.
Then he only remembers of the name Xehanort so Ansem decides to call him that.
He becomes Ansem appretice and then becomes to study hearts with Ansem.

From now on read the Secret Ansem reports (1 to 12,in KH2).

 

i think

yes it could be xehanort

BUT

if you look at KH2 Xehanort does not have the creeppy orange eyes that MASTER xehanort has


i think it could be "ANSEM" from kh1 and that the events of ansem the wises memorys happend earlyer than we thought

 

Er...
Heartless aways existed,the same with nobodies.
But it could be the first "Atirficial" Heartless or the first Emblem Heartless depending on what you're talking about.

 

Wait...I thought heartless existed longer than nobodies, since nobodies haven't appeared until CoM. Maybe they just didn't show up in KH1. Or did they?

 

Well,The Nobodies aways "existed",but we never saw any in KH1(We saw the org menbers in CoM,and one big Nobody from Marluxia) because Nomura had't thought about them yet,but they were aways there(Or not?They don't exist after all),the same for the org.

 

I think its Ven because the Ven we know and see in trailers is not the real Ven [THIS IS ONLY AN OPINION/SUGGESTION]

Edit: Maybe part of my later theories, but I won't write one about this yet.

 

Nobodies have existed as long as Heartless have. If Heartless were first discovered in the timeline of the game, then it is quite possible Nobodies could exist too, but not explicitly stated.

Correction. They have always existed as long as the Heartless existed.

Ansem is XEHANORT's heartless. End of story.

 

And since Heartless aways existed......

 

Heartless existed but only in the corners of the worlds as minor enemies. It was not until they were mass produced that more and more Nobodies started showing up. Of course, with the new Emblem Heartless, it is highly likely that all of Organization XIII was made Nobodies from this "surge of Heartless". The nobodies became a major thread after the Heartless did.