358/2 Days Who do you think Xion loves?

Discussion in 'Kingdom Hearts HD I.5 ReMIX' started by daisydog2, Jun 4, 2009.

?

Who do you think Xion would love?

  1. Riku

    69 vote(s)
    37.3%
  2. Roxas

    73 vote(s)
    39.5%
  3. Axel

    6 vote(s)
    3.2%
  4. A girl?...

    18 vote(s)
    9.7%
  5. other...

    19 vote(s)
    10.3%
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. fire mage Hollow Bastion Committee

    Joined:
    Jan 29, 2008
    Location:
    The World That Never Was/ Twlight Town
    36
    674
    I don't know. In the scene where the three of them were looking out at the beach she mentions that they are her best friends and she wants to be like them. I don't think she is stiffing Axel out or anything out of the friendship. If he didn't care he wouldn't have confronted her before, and has brought her back several times by carrying her back to their headquarters. Maybe it is an favor for Roxas, not sure though. He cares, about her in his own way, but may feel grudgeful, but still skeptical. The bond is not that strong, as Roxas but it is still there. Just by judging with his actions in the cutscenes.
    Roxas deeply cares for Xion and even shed a tear for her.

    As with those words I have in fact heard them before, but I can't find the scenes subbed with it to be sure though. It is an hassle to find anything translated on youtube.
     
  2. The Graceful Assassin It's Just Like Christmas Morning

    Joined:
    Sep 27, 2008
    Location:
    pl_badwater
    104
    Theres a trailer that says what Xion says on the beach. She says: "I wanna....I wanna be...I wanna be with you guys."
    Then Roxas says: "You already are." How do I know? Its in a trailer.
     
  3. LOL.

    That's enough of Soras for a lifetime, I think. Then again, Xion was a plot device and something to keep us interested anyway.

    The Sora/Roxas fans are going to have a field day with this one, however. They can justify why they like them now (even though it's still self-cest....;~; ). Actually, all fangirls will. Xion can form to whatever they wish...Dx. Just great. As if I haven't been scarred enough by accidental fanarts that happen to pop up. Searching images for a character has become difficult as it is.

    The threesome was meant to be the Soras. Axel doesn't belong.

    Those were actually on orders, both times. The moment in the mansion, the first thing he said as he came out of the portal irritated was, "leave all the dirty business to me...". He didn't react at all that much with knowing Xion's fate either. He just took in that it wasn't going to be the same anymore once he figured out who she was. In fact, he looked more upset about Roxas leaving than her death. On top of that, he got annoyed in some moments when Roxas spent more time with her, and when that happens, trust me when I say the friendship that matters is Roxas's in this situation. I takes a lot to get used to a add-on or newcomer. They even symbolized the competition with the "winner" stick. When you compare him talking and hanging out with Xion to Roxas, there's an obvious difference as well (while Roxas acts the same to both his friends regardless). Many things. Axel didn't hate her or dislike her, and he's the type of person who will be there for her, considering he isn't cold. And she was a true companion. But, Xion was nothing more than a friend of a friend, at best. The real connection between the two is Roxas. Without him and the idea of them eating ice cream together, it would have never happened. They aren't even a real trio, when you look at it. Unlike how Kairi and Riku could be friends without Sora, and how the novels proved that Axel didn't need Roxas to befriend and form a bond with Naminé (something that was carried over to the manga).

    And wait, since when does shedding tears and deeply caring for someone equals romantic love? Unless I misunderstood you. A close friend of his was dying.

    You don't even really need a translation, just hear what she's saying. She doesn't sound like she's about to say "suki", "daisuki", or ai/koi". There's nothing to indicate it, truthfully. To say "I love you" will be "daisuki da yo", which is the low form. For real passionate love, you say, "aishiteru". But this isn't a Japanese lesson. Point is, she's struggling with words, and was trying to get something out. Which she did. That him and Axel were her best friends. I didn't say she was trying to leave Axel out on purpose. Her frame of mind was weak as she was disappearing, so she couldn't think straight, and the one there was Roxas. But, it's not farfetched to say that she had a more closer friendship with Roxas than Axel. It's written all over the game.
     
  4. Mako Tsunami Kingdom Keeper

    Joined:
    Jan 18, 2009
    Location:
    In the ocean. Giggity.
    40
    904
  5. Joltrocks2 Moogle Assistant

    Joined:
    Jun 11, 2009
    Location:
    Where you find the best
    1
    6
    I say she likes roxas and her and riku dont make a good couple
     
  6. You should REALLY put spoiler tags. Just in case anyone who comes here want to join in the conversation, but doesn't want to spoil themselves.

    You're going a bit overboard there. Granted, I do expect for many things to happen with Xion on the lists now, after all, I've seen worse from fangirls. It never stops. And I hate it because I like searching images for the character I like, and get some avatars or signatures that I find laying around. But that's kind of a bad fantasy motif you got there >.<. I rather just keep the distance.

    And on top of that, I don't think Roxas really thought of Xion as her true form. He knew her the way she was in her death bed, and it was his friend in the end that died. No matter what she is, that doesn't change anything, and he wouldn't think less of her because she's actually a clone of a male. His other self's clone. Or memories. He cared for her regardless. Not to mention that in the scene he was quite out of it himself, with the beginning being that he forgot something to tell her, and then not really taking in the fact that she was actually dying. Xion reminded me too much of Repliku, actually. Same story, same fate. Except with a mixture of Roxas's own in KH2 extended.

    And Days actually placed the final nail on the AkuRoku coffin to me after watching it. Not that it would stop fangirls. But it really expanded the friendship that Axel thinks Roxas as his kid brother only. They even have a moment where they have girl talk, Axel mentioning how difficult they are, and that you shouldn't press the wrong buttons, which is written in Roxas's diary (then again, other than Naminé, and Xion before the revelation, the only other girl he talked to was Larxene. And she's not exactly the best role model, lol. Though I would think he was speaking of experiences in his past life). In one of the Secret Reports that you get at the end of the game, Axel then mentions that when he's with Roxas (and Xion), memories of his childhood flood back, and he gets a weird feeling. Nostalgia, maybe, I wouldn't know. Hell, there are hints throughout the game that Axel and Saïx knew each other before becoming Nobodies, and they get just as much screen time talking together. The defense against AkuRoku keeps piling, and truthfully, can't wait for this game to come over and make it permanent.

    Considering I talk to 16 year olds and I'm 19, I don't think that makes me required to be a pedophile just because I have friends that are that age >.>. Axel is not any of that. Fangirls just want him to be.
     
  7. fire mage Hollow Bastion Committee

    Joined:
    Jan 29, 2008
    Location:
    The World That Never Was/ Twlight Town
    36
    674
    I never liked AkuRoku so in a way I am glad that they stopped that little thing from going on. I always thought that they were just friends and this game proves it. Maybe it was intentionally done by adding Xion in the mix was to halt the relationship going in the wrong direction. There are things that make more sense with Roxas departure, but still alot more mysteries now concerning the organization as whole. The missed days and so forth. The girl talk thing was funny considering if not his past experiences he might of meant Larxene. lol. I wouldn't doubt that for a second. Now with Saix knowing Axel I don't know if they did in fact know each or not before becoming nobodies. I wouldn't be able to tell without reading the conversations, but it being in japanese I never would be able to know without word by mouth or unless they are translated somewhere. Heck it would be good of what the members were saying to others and even Roxas.

    Hell no. I speak to people that are younger than myself and it doesn't bother me nor would it even come remotely close to pedophile. It is stupid that people would even mention such things. No he isn't that either. Just stupid accusiations or an imagination gone wild.
     
  8. Love Kingdom Keeper

    Joined:
    Dec 14, 2006
    Gender:
    Female
    Location:
    In a world where the sunset casts slender shadows
    61
    783
    Personally I think Xion loves Riku more. Shes always asking him questions , then tone of her voice when around him seems like a gentle loving tone. But if you guys want to pull Roxas into it, whatever :/. Hes got Namine already.

    XionXRiku ftw
     
  9. Xion being who she is, isn't exactly what I would call the perfect yaoi shield, if you get my drift. In fact, I would think she opened up a pandora's box for the fangirls in general, making things worse. As well as giving justification to some of the pairings they support. Xion can transform into anything. I'll let that end there. Either way, the evidence against AkuRoku, ironically enough, was build up by the two boys just hanging together and talking by themselves in the game. No "girl" involved to break it, you just see it that they do not have that kind of relationship that most fangirls think they have. Their actions resemble those of best friends and brothers. Axel is more of a guide to Roxas, and Roxas himself looks up to him (which is kind of funny, actually): "Axel knows everything, so I thought he'd know about best friends". Taken exactly from the translations of Roxas's diary entries. The thing that bothers me the most about AkuRoku is that they take away the actual innocence of the friendship and twist it into something unapproachable.

    As for him talking about Larxene in that statement of girls being difficult, lol, I guess we will never know. In the short stories when they first meet, Axel is kind of "o.O?" at her throughout the conversation. But it can go both ways, truthfully.

    And I think I could show this, about Axel's entry in one of the Secret Reports. Throughout the game, you could see that him and Saïx spent a lot of the time talking, and Axel's real name was revealed in one of the conversations. In one of the days, Saïx said that Axel had changed since Castle Oblivion. This is what really solidifies the clues that they had known each other before they had become Nobodies. In this little excerpt:

    And we cannot forget this Novel scene, considering it adds to it perfectly:


    Welcome to the KH fandom.

    :P
     
  10. TheCrownedRoxas Twilight Town Denizen

    7
    241

    How can Xion be Roxas? Thats really odd.
     
  11. SamuraiHerusan Merlin's Housekeeper

    Joined:
    Jun 15, 2009
    Location:
    Panda Town
    1
    26
    I say Riku because most of the people here are saying Riku.
     
  12. ultima_sora Traverse Town Homebody

    Joined:
    May 12, 2007
    Location:
    Up your bum ^^
    3
    128
    LMAO SO TRUE

    and for riku and axell.... noooooo
    for riku it would be like making out with
    sora
    and that's just plain wronggg =P
    and for axel she would have to like tippie-toe up to kiss him xD
    i could imagine her being like "I can't reach!!!!!" xD
     
  13. Dredica SNES was the best.

    Joined:
    Sep 6, 2007
    Gender:
    Male
    Location:
    Press Ctrl+W to find out
    102
    From all of those screenshots of Riku and her together I automatically assumed that they were a couple. I mean, Roxas and Namine, and Sora and Kairi, it would just make sense for Xion and Riku to be together. Didn't she talk about Riku alot in the game too? I mean, from the cutscenes that I've seen that are subbed, she mentions Riku a lot.

    All of the girl fans would get that RikuxSora yoai shit too, because Xion is Sora.
     
  14. Fairyharp Merlin's Housekeeper

    Joined:
    Mar 13, 2009
    2
    25
    personally i see xion getting with roxas
     
  15. Nova We left a scar size extra-large.

    Joined:
    Jul 11, 2008
    Location:
    *Somewhere In The Stratosphere ♥
    97
    Er... i thought they didn't have emotions x3
     
  16. Sora_Gaiden Traverse Town Homebody

    Joined:
    Jun 23, 2009
    Location:
    Rolling around at the speed of sound!
    6
    111
    Xion belongs with Riku, considering that she's a clone of Sora, and if Sora is Riku's best friend, Xion should get along with her, and become her boyfriend.
     
  17. ROXASORGXII Destiny Islands Resident

    Joined:
    Jul 1, 2009
    3
    54
    riku its his partner.......
    they are soo obious and cute!!!!
     
  18. kingdomheartslover4ever Moogle Assistant

    Joined:
    Jul 7, 2009
    1
    2
  19. Axelxxx45 Destiny Islands Resident

    Joined:
    Dec 24, 2008
    Location:
    in the real world, blowing away fantasies.
    1
    99
    Xion loves Roxas, as Kairi to Sora.
     
  20. Twilight Tulip Moogle Assistant

    Joined:
    Jul 5, 2009
    Location:
    In my imagination. ; )
    0
    2
    I, personally, don't think she loves anyone. They are all merely close friends.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.