The Yugioh Card Duel Arena 11.0

Marquis, Kalakaua and Kelly are fine. The rest are too strong.

 

Here's the ones that didn't make it:




Danny's basically the 'Cyber Dragon' of the archetype.[DOUBLEPOST=1425699509][/DOUBLEPOST]Can I help it if I'm a 'Hawaii Five-O' fan?[DOUBLEPOST=1425700451][/DOUBLEPOST]Got some Spells for the archetype:

 

HQ shouldn't be able to add itself. I don't think Vest makes sense for preventing targeting as well as destruction, but I think the card is okay how it is.

I'm going to say okay to everything except HQ (until it can't add itself), but I expect that Yakumo wont like Steve, and it seems a bit borderline to me, so I probably wouldn't overrule him.

 

At least you're lenient, SirFred. That's all I can ask.

 

All approved.

 

Steve don't pass, just because it can search itself afterwards.
Hedquaters are OK for now.
I don't see how Bulletproof Vest make sense to stop effects and prevent targeting so I will say no, just because its a huge design error. Also it prevents any card destruction of a monster with effects, so even more no.
To rest I'm going to say ok for now.

 

Not sure how I missed that but noticed that headquarters could self search..

As for vest, I think as long as it's destruction, it makes sense. Like, you'd survive being shot by Barrel Dragon.

Maybe make it "The first time each turn that the equipped monster would be destroyed, it is not." or something to that effect?

 

In hedquaters case its something like malefic world, its not strong enough to nerf it. As for vest, prevent first destruction from anything by destroying itself seems far more reasonable than surviving falling into dark hole just because you have vest. After all vest uses its durability afterwards and just wont be able to protect you as good as before afterwards.

 

I agree. Right now, the card is better off being renamed "The Tank".

 

Oh that's right it shouldn't be able to search itself I see what you mean.

 

If we're going off logic like you did with vest..
You can take a gun out of a building. You can take a vest out of a building. You can even take people out of a building..
But you can't take the building out of itself and still have the original building. That is logically impossible.

 

You can take materials to build new building. Then its possible. But ok, I have nothing against saying no to it just because you think its logically impossible.

 

Hmm.. I guess you can actually do it.. but it would be both highly unpractical and difficult.

 

That should be good enough.

 

What we were saying is a vest should have durability. It would make no sense for a vest to be able to save you from a machine gun as it shoots you a thousand times over. Vest can resist destruction by effects indefinitely. Well, if you want it to stay that way, I'm fine with that too. All approved.

May I suggest making all your normal monsters into pendulums? That would make them cooler than they are now.

 

Pendulums, eh? Only problem with that is that I'm not sure what effects Kelly, Kalakaua and the Carriers would have as Pendulums (or what scale they would be).

 

Hmm.. I'll think of something for them later.

 

I mean, I was thinking scale 1 for Kelly and scale 7 for Kalakaua or vice versa. The Carriers....scale 4 for Grand Marquis and scale 8 for Camaro. That's as far as I have gotten.

 

For now I can accept Steve. Once we see dem pendulums its different story. HQ could be written other, nicer way, but its effect is clear enough so it passes. Vest gets nope, because you can throw guy with it on to dark hole thousand times and he still won't be destroyed. Makes sense? No. And I believe this show follows at least some kind of logic.

 

Added the 'once per turn' stipulation.