The Yu-Gi-Oh! Card Duel Arena!

I still haven't gotten an answer regarding hand refill. Do you get five cards plus your Draw Phase (so six cards at the start of your Main Phase) or five in total?

Actually I didn't chain your Heavy Storm. Volcanic Counter is a response to an attack, and you didn't have any usable face-down cards at that time.
So my Counter doesn't get redirected.
So I haven't lost yet.
You negated my damage but that's basically it.

Your LP: 7500
My LP: 4500

I still have 4 face-downs left. I counter your attack with one of them: Nightmare Wheel.

Before I begin my turn I'd like to know whether you counter this move or not. It'll have an effect on what I do during my next move.

 

oh ok.I chain my facedown royal decree to your nightmare wheel now I activate card destruction and the cards discarded are necro gardna, silva warlord of the dark world, e- hero necroshade, and 2 dark grephors now Silva is special summoned to the field And I remove from play necroshade to special summon elemental hero neos now I attack you directly dealing 4800 life point damage

 

Xakota! I Challenge You To a Duel! Get Ready To Defend Your Title!

Cause I'm Going All-Out!

 

I thought he could only get a signal on the crapper. :P

 

Lol he's back from his vacation now.

 

oh, alright

 

@Jaden: Dude, get in line. He's already agreed to a duel with DeadHeart when he got back, and he agreed to a duel with me afterwards. :P

Your Elemental Hero Neos or your other monsters can't attack me, since I activated my trap during the Battle Phase. I specified this in my previous post. Thus, your combo can only have taken place as soon as Main Phase 2.

Either way I counter your Royal Decree with my Trap Jammer, which I can due to its higher spell speed.

2 face-down cards left on either side.
Will you continue to try and negate my Nightmare Wheel or leave it at this?

 

actually that doesn't negate royal decree because you're not in your battle phase so Royal decree still goes on

 

I countered her during the Battle Phase; doesn't that make it illegal for her to redo her Main Phase 1? Something about not redoing your move
In that case she must have activated it during her Main Phase 2, which means she can't have attacked me at all. But very well, the Trap Jammer activation didn't connect. I'll grant you that. That would mean I still have three cards face-down though.
All in all this may be a better predicament than I originally planned.

 

technically it is my move for that turn, but you cant activate any traps. Only spell cards or monsters that destroy traps can save you

 

well one of your facedowns will have to be trap jammer and it still can't be activated due to royal decree already being activated

 

This is the reason why I told people that they need to declare what phase they are entering when they make their moves...(-_-;

 

true
___________

 

@Jaden: Yeah I know what you mean. But that's the question. If you counter something in the Battle Phase, can your opponent respond by redoing her entire move?
@Aqua: Right. So two face-downs and Trap Jammer.

Well yeah I know it's your turn but see:
You made a move, and entered a Battle Phase (that was before your combo with Card Destruction etc.). I activated a trap during the Battle Phase.
So now you just redo your move? Is that legal?

 

Oh Man! Where's Xakota when we need him?!?!?!?:why?:

 

I chained royal decree to your nightmare wheel so it was already activated so you couldn't negate the activation of Royal decree and destroy it

 

Yes I can, as long as I chain it with a card that has a higher spell speed. Like Trap Jammer. Royal Decree isn't activated until the entire chain is resolved.

 

I may not know much about the game, but it seems to me that the obvious answer is no.
The whole move up until the exact moment you countered would be still be valid and set.
Otherwise, if you counter someone, they could just redo their entire move like it never happened, which is illegal.
They can only redo what happened after you counter because your counter would mean they wouldn't be able to do what they originally did.

Also, in hand refill, you still do get your draw phase.


And X2,

You keep leaving out images.
Especially the cards you discard with Hand Destruction.

 

trap jammer negates the activation of the card and it was already activated so there's nothing to negate the activation of

 

This is right.