Kingdom Hearts II Roxas's keyblades. Real or Fake?

I didn't notice that, Sora released his heart at Hollow Bastion (creating Roxas/Namine) but made the promise to Kairi at the end of KH1 (right?)
So thats a good point. But the Keyblade's don't represent the PROMISE itself, it represents Sora's MEMORY of Kairi. The fact about the promise could just be that the promise (he'll come back or he's always there?) has always been there, just not stated outloud

 

I thought that Sora made his side of the promise at the end. O_o
Didn't Kairi give him the good luck charm in Traverse Town? Sora already promised to bring it back.

Sadly I don't know if that effects anything or not D:

 

if you guys think keychains are people memories... then who made ultima's memories? i wanna know that xD cuz whoever did had an awesome life :O

 

Roxas with keyblades fake? Maybe in that TwlightTown virtual reality town when Diz was controllling it, but besides that I doubt it.

 

Actually the only thing we can say that was a Digital Weapon for Roxas would be his Kingdom Key. Oathkeeper and Oblivion HAVE to be real...no idea how he summoned them though.

 

Okay now I am confused. He has the kingdom Key in the digital world also, but in the manga he has Oblivion and Oathkeeper. Although he has Obilvion when he fights Sora. So which one is he techincally supposed to have?

 

Digital Kingdom Key is a "Replica" of his original from days...Well I think that.
I haven't read the manga, He wields both in there right? He also wields both in the Second Axel battle, yet it wasn't summoned with data surrounding it when it appears like when Roxas obtains the Digital Kingdom Key.
....Doesn't he have both agaisnt Sora too? O-o

Oathkeeper and Oblivion are his main weapons since he Dual Wields. Yet I'm still completely confused x_x

 

The Moogles
haha idk probably
or it could be ALL his memories, which would make it the superior weapon as oposed to the the other keyblades made from SPECIFIC memories

 

If keychain represent memory, then I get 3 question (a lot, eh?)

1. How about ultima weapon's keychain? and why they have different appearance? (sorry, maybe this question out of topic)
2. Roxas didn't have any memory about Sora (Roxas is special nobody, right?). If you're Roxas and can't remember about your true self, how can you remember about your true self's friends? (right?)
3. Sora's memory had been recovered at KH 2. So, why he lost all his old keychains and at some worlds, it replaced by similar keychain? (like divine rose in KH 1 and Rumbling Rose in KH 2)

 

actually they are real. i dont know how he got the keychains but i DO know that sora didnt have them when roxas did. when u get oathkeeper from hayner in twilight town u get the keychain after they come in contact with kairi. as for oblivion riku fights roxas,wins, and uses oblivion in the battle. later on he gives the keychain to sora when they meet up again. basicly he steals it from roxas after beating him. oh and the reason roxas can dual weild *SPOILER FROM 358/2 DAYS* is because after he fights xion he absorbs her power and takes her keyblade. then he heads back for the castle to destroy kingdom hearts and is stopped by riku.