Kingdom Hearts II Roxas?

At the world that never was, you see a scene of Sora fighting Roxas.
Wasn't Roxas joined with Sora?

Maybe he like...came out of Sora.
But, didn't he lose his memory of the Organization?

 

I do not know the exact details, but the reason Roxas fights Sora is because of Axel's death.

Yes, but as Sora gained back his memories, Roxas also gained his back. Right before he fights Axel for the second time, Roxas has all his memories back, it is the same with Sora.

 

They joined when Sora was awakened in Twilight Town but Axel dying caused Roxas to remember his days in the Organization and he split from Sora thinking he killed Axel so they fought and Roxas went back inside him and showed up at the end, that's what I think.

 

[Spoilers]

I was told that the fight only happened in Sora's mind, which makes sense, because he was the only one who saw Roxas in the first place. So, maybe it was a mental fight.

Edit: Roxas had already remembered Axel as his old best friend in Twilight Town, and Axel's death triggered the fight.

 

roxas wasn't joined with sora yet. at the end of the game he joins with soar as namine and kairi. and remeber how no one else could see the fight. remember all the stuff that happpened in twilit town with roxas. maybe that's a nobody power.

 

The Twilight Town at the start of the game was a computer simulation created by DiZ. (remember Axel saying "This town is his creation right?") The nobodies broke in which is why so many weird stuff was happening, and Roxas was the only one who noticed (well most of the time) as everyone else were computer images anyway.
He joined with Sora shortly afterwards, where else would he be for the rest of the game? I agree with Stardust that what happened in The World that Never Was was only in Sora's mind. It even takes place on the station of awakening. If it had been real don't you think they would have fought in the real world that never was?

 

well he could have transfered them to another arena like the first xemnas fight. that battle was real

 

i think it was in sora's mind too, like zakura rabbit and stardust said, but for the reasons kingdom-fan said...basically the same thing! :p but what i dont get is why roxas didnt remember anything in the first place...i know, probably a stupid question, but can somebody please answer in a pm or something?:o




.........will this be considered spam?? LOL

 

Hm....yeah, I agree that the Roxas fight must've happened in Sora's mind. It's sorta similar to Ichigo vs. his Hollow half. (I'm referring to Bleach)

 

Yah
think it all happend in sora's mind
because nobody could see roxas except sora

but otherwise I don't
because it happens at the same place where roxas
fought the twilight thorn and that wasn't in his mind or was it

 

Roxas doesn't remember the Organization at the start of the game because DiZ deleted those memories, to prevent the organization from taking it back. He said so himself: "He needs a new personality, to throw of his pursuers".
However at the last day, when Roxas enters the mansion his memories start to return, and at the end when he fights Axel the last time, and later fuses with Sora he's gotten all his memories back;)

 

Spoiler:

Axel's death triggered Roxas' appearance to Sora in TWTNW.Axel touched Sora's heart and awakened Roxas because like somebody thought,maybe he thought Sora killed Axel. Maybe Roxas fought Sora mentally but Goofy said that the cloaked fogure fought him and he disappeared.So it must be an actual one.

 

Wait... Was Sora in the Fake Twilight Town? Or was it just a data Sora because he was in it at the End of the 6th Day and there was no way Roxas could of found the Real Twilight Town.

 

The real Sora was out battling baddies.

 

Er...no? He was in the same flower pod he'd been in ever since CoM.
I think maybe the basement was kind of the connection point between the two worlds. So DiZ may have added in a copy of Sora there too:p
Strange part is, Sora actually goes to the digital Twilight Town at the end, before going to TWTNW...

 

So if Roxas knew the Password for the Computer then he would of made it to the real Twilight Town or gone to Organization XIII, shame you couldn't go into the Portal. Anyway so that was Roxas crying when Sora was going on the train? When Roxas was inside of Sora and crying so Sora cried but it wasn't really him crying.

 

mhmm i see...thank you! i can be pretty slow sometimes...:p

 

Roxas hadn't joined Sora until after the battle, when all the bright white light surrounded them and he said, 'you're a good other'. Then, when Sora and Kairi came in contact with each other before the Xemnas battles where you are attacked by the flying castle, Roxas and Namine come out.

I think Sora was in the real Twilight Town and somehow Roxas went there, too. It's my speculations but I think that's pretty much a correct wayt ot put it.

 

Yeah.It was the real Roxas crying.He knows the real HPO but they do not know him.Only their data do.