Video Please give me some feedback, people....

Alright, I made my first two vids about a year ago, and now I'm hooked. Unfortunately, I don't have any friends who really get into these types of things... so it falls to you guys.

Please tell me what you think of my first two attempts..

A Riku Tribute

A Crisis Core Tribute

 

The Riku tribute was okay, but I didn't like the slow motion effect you did. 8/10 The Crisis Core tribute was amazing. Extremely well done matching the footage with the lyrics. 10/10

 

Your Riku tribute flows with the song. I like it.

And you FF7CC Tribute is awesome. It really does flow, and Linkin park is awesome! x3

Keep up your awesome work and you'll get better! :3

 

i.agree.the.riku.one.did.not.have.enough.like.pulse.and.things.on.teh.strong.beets

but.the.CC.one.was.really.good.hitting.strong.beets.and.lotta.clips.used

keep.up.the.good.work.and.hope.to.see.more.from.you

 

The riku one in my opion i didnt really enjoy it sorry. It had a good flow but i wasnt getting into it.
The CC was better. It followed the lyrics which gives a plus there. There was a lot of effects that were really unneeded. Also which was a kinda disappointment was you used linkin park. Lp is way over used in amvs.

Riku tribute 4/10
CC tribute 6/10

 

If the music is good, it shouldnt matter if it is overused. That's like saying "KH/Naruto/whatever show is overused, you shouldnt use it" or "Vegas/wmm/whatever is overused", etc. etc.

I say use what you like, not what others tell you is good. I happen to like more heavily 'AMV'd' bands.

The only reason some of them seem overused is because of all the crap for them on Youtube. Ignore the crap, and focus on the good videos (no offense to the original poster. I am not saying yours is crap.)

 

The Riku tribute wasn't really good but the Crisis Core tribute was amazing. =D

The rhythym matching was perfect but at times you could've added more to some extra beats, but w/e.

Keep on working and improving, and you will be an amazing WMM editor. =D

 

Alright, thank you all!
I like to hear both the positive and negative feedback on my vids- because only then do I know how to move forward in my editing skills.

I have one other CC video to my credit, so if you wouldn't mind taking a quick glance at it as well, I would greatly appreciate it.

Watch in high quality please!

Zack/Aerith Tribute

Once again, thanks people!