Digital Art Please comment, pick and rate these sigs!

Okay, so I made 3 sigs recently, and I need help deciding which one I should use. Just tell me which one do you like the best, reason why, and also if you know any way I could improve, please tell me!

Here they go:







Okay, that's all of them!

 

I like the third one the best, I think IMO that the other two are too dark in appearance. But I fail with stuff like that so you can ignore me if you want ^^ I do like the others as well but the third is def my favourite :)​

 

Thanks for replying. I have to get working on avatars as well, I might post some up if I make more than one, but it depends.

The third one took pretty long for me to make, because of lack of options when starting. A blank white picture with a robot...I had to be creative.

 

Well you should be pleased it came out so well then ^^ but I have to ask what is the picture on the second one because I can't fully make it out?​

 

It's a creature from Guild Wars: Eye of the North.

 

*relieved*

I thought it was but I wanted to check first! anywayz excellent work on all 3 IMO ^^​

 

Dude, stop murdering your renders by drowning them in effects! D:
Seriously, the point of having a render is so it can be seen xD;
Make the render more defined, by blending it in a little bit, making it look natural. Sharpen them up, blurr parts of the background.
Take a look at some of my sigs, Darky's sigs, and Eclipse's.
Should show you a few things about blending.
The effects are great for a novice, but try and read some tutorials, so you can progress through the stages of graphics-dom.... o_O
Anyways, good job on them.

 

Oh my god, you can't even see your renders. They are underneath like all of the effects. Also try working on your blending...PLEASE !!

I like #2 best because you can actually make out what the render looked like.

 

Yeah, I know, drowned out, but I don't really use backgrounds, because I don't have any. And the next one isn't any better either. I don't know much about anything, and I'm using a trail with 11 days left...so....I'm trying my best here.

Well, here's another one.



Yes, it's over-effected either as well.

In number 3 you can see that robot clearly! What's wrong with it?

 

The problem is it isn't drawing toward one section, which is supposed to be the render. Because of the lines or...something, it makes the whole sig less to look at IMO.

Your first two sigs are like blind to me. I can't see the render in them. Try getting brushes and smudging. That's what I do. Try looking at a few members sigs around here, it helps.

And for your Roxas sigg. Hm...I won't say it's bad, 'cuz it ain't. The flow is getting chopped because of certain effects. I can't really seem to tell where. Once again, try looking at other members siggehz and a few tuts. That should help.

 

Thanks for that. I really should go find some editor with more...options. You can see in all of them I'm repeating a lot of effects. Also, I need a good render to work with, I'm always short on those. I can always reuse, see how they come out different I guess.

Another last three, hope I did better on these:

 

i kinda liked 2,7 and 5. well..... five not so much.
good work man!