I really like the colors and effects of the sig. The dimensions heightwise are a little bit too large for me, but otherwise I think it's a fine sig. 8/10
Yeah, I'm kinda picky with cutting down on height. Cropping images isn't my favorite thing, cause it cuts down on what you get to see, though I suppose that can add to the overall result. Thanks for the comment.
i like the colors the red and black look good together, overall good ^^ 8.5/10 EDIT: i like the shattered glass look, its a good touch
I would've chose a better stock, considering this one makes him look uglier. Although, I do see you're trying to have a theme of some sort, so, the stock is good as it is. But yeah, not much CnC, but still kind of average. Keep practicing and try learning different techniques.