Digital Art Naruto Sig (A bit dark)

What I need most are some text advice.
Don't be harsh whatsoever.

 

I'm not going to be harsh, because I like it!

I think the dark works well in the sig.

8.5/10.

 

I don't like the font.....
I'll give it a 7.5/10

 

Dude that came out nice! But yeh, perhaps diffrent text :/ 8.7/10

 

Text = BAD

One thing to keep in mind with text is, never have too much. It's a much better idea to only have a few words. Too much takes up a ton of room and makes the sig look horrible.

Also, a simple font is always the way to go. Never get too fancy or complicated because it often ruins the sig.

One more thing is, never have the text stick out more then the focal point, which in this case if Naruto.

Overall, 6/10

 

I have to agree with Cin. Though it is a good job, the text just draws all of the attention away from the render and the sig itself suffers. If you have noticed, a lot of sigs that have tons text usually have most of it small, and the focal text large. There is nothing wrong with your sig besides the text, so I'll give it a 7/10 since it did turn out pretty good.

 

This is probably one of the only times I find rating necessary.

3/10

(This is where there constructive criticism comes)

The text doesn't go good here at all. It's slapped on and simple. No editing whatsoever, from what I can tell. The colour white isn't a necessary colour here. More like a higher shade of blue would make more sense.. The render, is blended in a bit. But it's just under a layer of clouds. No relevance to the sig there, at all...

And finally, the BG. It's good, but it has no main purpose. It's mainly a blue layer with brush-layers on-top. Which is basic..so I don't really care so much. xD

Keep at it. Read up on some tut's. :)

 

This is where I don't agree too much. I think that if the text wasn't white adn instead blended more with the background, it might look good and flow well with such a background. Of course you could also change the backgorund by adding light effects but it looks like the sig is during the night sso I like the bg.
Also about the text....well I think you should follow most Cin's advice about it.:)
Overall 7/10