358/2 Days Namine or Xion?

Don't make me choose.

 

namine, duh.

She's written so much better for one thing, and she's far less annoying.

She's also nicer, and I have a huge soft spot from pretty much everything that came out of CoM and II.

 

I really liked Namine as a character, but I like Xion even more! I'll have to cast my vote for Xion! ;)

 

I'd have to say Naminé. I feel bad for xion and all but I don't like her that much. Call me heartless. I don't care. Nope. (;-; don't hurt me)

 

I honestly didn't like Xion as much. I didn't like Namine much either, but she showed a lot more emotion and caring that Xion did in my eyes.

She also had a much more integral plot that lasted more than a game than Xion did overall in the Kingdom Hearts series. I am for Namine.

 

But she isn't a person. She's a puppet.

 

I started on 358/2 Days, and I haven't played the numbered series yet. So, while my obvious answer is Xion, I'm really not qualified to answer this question. I will say this though. If, when I play the main games, Namine (or anyone, really) can top Xion... I will bake cookies for the entire staff of Square Enix (all of them) and deliver them personally.

 

I honestly, deeply detest Xions' existence. Another typical sob story rehash of both Roxas' and Riku Replica's inner turmoil, of forced tragedy, and of forced pity, to try and forget that this character came out from literally nowhere and never existed in game canon until 358/2 Days. The game kept telling me so much that I had to feel sorry for this random addition that I eventually felt the complete opposite. People with soft hearts would fall for it easily, but not me. Then they shoehorned her into Axel and Roxas to make another repetitive SoRiKai trio, proving that Roxas really was just another Sora (to me) and had no individually other than resulting in the same copycat group of friends.

Of course we know more about Xion. She practically stole the spotlight from Roxas, who is supposed to be the "main character", while he sat on his arse wondering about the events going on and being brainless. Naminé, on the other hand, was important to CoM and did her part, yet didn't overshadow the hero. Nor did Sora stay there floating mindlessly, doing nothing. She's the one that deconstructs the Mary Sue.

Xion is a straight example no matter how many want to deny it.

This is only the tip of the iceberg with my issues with 358/2 Days and a short explanation. There are so many issues.

Naminé. All the damn way.

Any time, any day, any vast galaxy.

 

Well... I've gotta say I don't know... Maybe Xion 'cause we get to know her in 358/2, but if there would be a game telling Namine's story, maybe I would choose her :P
I´m really curious if there is gonna be more of Xion and Namine in the next games

 

Being the biggest Roxas fan (just look at my name) I have had trouble deciding myself, Namine is quite and shy while Xion is a bit of a tomboy, whats funny is that even though Namine messed with Roxas' memories of the Orginization and removed Xion entirly I just cant seem to hate her. but at the same time Xion and Roxas worked together. they were friends who laughed, cried and eventually fought to the death, a better love story then twilight am i right? They are both awesome and in my mind I think Xion is stronger I cant just say Namine is weaker so im goinh to say their equal Can't I have both?

 

Namine, if you piss her off or attack her firends (if she had them) she would shatter your mind like a baseball through your neighbour's window. also Xion was erased simply because that is what happens when a replica dies, all that they were and all that could have been is ripped away.