Birth by Sleep My theory for the ending of Birth by Sleep

Ok so here is my theory, and tell me what you might think. Ok so, Terra, Aqua, and Ven defeat Master Xehanort and Vanitas and they retreat back to their castle or something. Master Xehanort and Vanitas stand in their castle and Master Xehanort feels he can become much stronger by giving him self in to the darkness. He turns himself into a heartless and takes a new form, the form of Xehanort's Heartless in Kingdom Hearts 1. He realizes that his new power is great, and then he turns over to Vanitas and tells him to give in to the darkness too. He tells Vanitas not to worry, for his former form will take form in one of his future apprentices (Riku). He then turns Vanitas into a heartless, making him take a new form also, the form of the guardian that protects Xehanort's Heartless in Kingdom Hearts 1. While Master Xehanort transforms, his heart leaves a shell behind that wanders out the castle and into a distant valley. The shell of the heart then turns into a dusk, then it evolves into a human, becoming Xemnas. Xemnas makes a black coat appear on him and then he stands on a cliff overlooking the valley where the keyblade war took place, he then realizes that he has no heart, and he starts planning to gather more "Nobodies" to help him capture Kingdom Hearts. He whispers to himself saying that he will start an organization that will overthrow all. The scene will then go back to Xehanort's Heartless and the Guardian talking. Xehanort's Heartless will say that Terra, Aqua, and Ven's time is over, and that a new keyblade master is coming. He will then look into his crystal ball and see a scene of Sora and Riku as little kids having a wood sword fight, with the screen slowly zooming in on Sora's face, and then the credits come on.

 

Not a bad theory, but there are a few flaws:

1. MX is not Xehanort's Heartless. Xehanort's Heartless is the heartless of, get ready for it... XEHANORT, Ansem the Wise's apprentice (working alongside Braig (Xigbar), Dilan (Xaldin), Even (Vexen), Aeleus (Lexeaus), and Ienzo (Zexion))!

2. Riku wasn't really XH's apprentice, but he did sort-of fuse with him, so I see where you get that part of theory.

Now, for some parts that don't really make sense, no offense:

1. A crystal ball? Really?

2. How, exactly does Xemnas make a black coat appear? And if he supposedly made the black coat, how did DiZ?

3. What castle are you talking about? TVA's Master and MX share the same castle, if I'm not mistaken.

4. (This one, it sort-of makes sense, but sort-of doesn't) If Xemnas was supposedly a Dusk, to start, and evolved into a human, does that mean Roxas did too? It couldn't because in a scene from 358/2 Days and FM+, it shows Roxas's 'birth', so to speak.

Other than that, seems like a good theory.

 

It's a castle that Master Xehanort formed when he left, an old abandoned castle that he took over.

 

I'm not that up-to-date with the infromation, but, could, like, post a picture or something? 'Cause I have no idea what you're talking about.

 

no im totally making up the castle part up. but he did leave and Terra Aqua and Ven are searching for him

 

Phew. I was like, "Did I miss something here?" at first. But, yeah, I agree with you on the TVA are searching for him.

 

The main problem with this idea, is time. Your ideas don't fit the storyline. You have events occurring fast and early.

Heartless didn't exist at this time. And this skips the whole Xehanort going to Ansem the Wise and becoming the heartless we fought in KH1. Otherwise messing with the storyline.

But the guardian looks nothing like Riku. And again there are no heartless at this time.

Again, Xemnas wasn't born until 9 years before KH1. Plus Master Xehanort's body is too old to be Xemnas. Xemnas is around 30 years old. Master Xehanort isn't that young.

I'm not sure if nobodies can be born in sunset horizon, but Xemnas wasn't born alone. There were 5 others. The other students of Ansem the Wise. And again too early.

Crystal ball? What happens to TVA?

The only thing you might have right, is this.

Castle oblivion was formed by someone ther than the Organization. They just found it. The castle bears a similar mark of that of Master Xehanort's keyblade. Master Xehanort might have created it.

 

Very possible. But I think Marluxia made it

 

Made what, Castle Oblivion?