I usually don't edit manga caps because it doesn't really suit my style, but sometimes you've got to experiment~
Which manga is this? I want to try my hand at some manga editing >:B But anyhow, I think this is pretty good. I really can't comment a lot on the effects since it's really simple. But the feel you gave the whole thing is nice. I would probably add a bit more shadows and lights. But there's really nothing to complain about.
I really like it, as usual. The colors are toned down and at the same time, where there is color, it's quite striking. I don't exactly love the manga cap you chose, but it's good nonetheless.
I like it. Like Chev, I want to know what manga it is from. Very nice. You need to get better at adding credit text, though. It is the same annoying thing every time.
I really like the texture you used for this. It almost looks as though it was a painting. I especially love the quote you put there. It's really cute. I wish I knew what manga it was though. For some reason though, the manga looks familiar to me.
I like it. I like it a lot. The colors go very well with the picture, and for some reason, I really like the (something that looks like) splatter in the bottom center. Part of the original picture or added?