Birth by Sleep Multiple theories in one #2

This is going to sound like the most stupid Dark Soldier ID theory but what if Dark Soldier becomes Saix because out of all the people in that castle Saix was the second in command. If not Dark Soldier then Saix must be in BBs somewhere because why not have the strongest as your second in command...because if you look at it Xemnas picks the strongest for the more personal missions

2nd strongest Saix= second in command
3rd strongest- Axel= sent to CO looking for room of sleep and awakening
4th- Marluxia heads CO
5th- Vexen heads expirements
any comments?

 

I've heard some pretty bad ones lol, this is pretty good, but It don't think it will work.
Saix can't use the keyblade, and never made any hint or mention of a keyblade using past.

True, but according to 358/2 Days. Him and Axel weren't all that much loyal to Xemnas. They planned to overthrow him and hopefully use whatever was in the room of waking. He has never mede any reference of his past that would indicate he's the DS

Saix will be in BBS. As will Axel's other,

Spoiler

Lea, they were pretty good friends

This is the offical order of the organization's power

1. Xemnas
2. Roxas
3. Xaldin
4. Lexeaus

These four are the most powerful members of the Organization

 

well the ones I listed were the ones he could've seen as qualified and close because Saix foir example keep your friends close and your enemies closer and the xemnas and Xigbar don't have keyblades but some people are believing that one of them is MX.

As for Saix an Axel being friends that also shoots down my theory because that itself and the order they joined but the Axel and Saix overthrowing the Org. proves my theory because it's been widely theorized that Ds overthrows MX

 

So why did Xemnas make Marluxia the head of CO? Xemnas knew of him being a traitor and still sent him off to be the lord of a castle. Also if you noticed this line in KH2 from Saix to Xemnas after Saix asks if Kingdom Hearts is ready

If this line indicates what I think it does. Xemnas might have been aware of Saix being a traitor as well. The charade being Saix's being loyal to him

Yeah, I personally think Saix is speical, but not DS special. Hiss role in BBS will hopefully highlight this as well was Axel's past.

A theory can't prove an idea.
And the two theories you stated don't match up. If DS betrayed MX once why would he's nobody not expect the same?