Mafia [Mafia] The Book of Names ~ GAME OVER (MAFIA WINS)

And you're not giving us many reasons to lower you on the read list.

 

Oh guys, I've changed the settings on my logs so that anybody can edit it. Obviously when I die, I can't add to it, but I've made it so that other people are able to update it if you so wish. Likewise you can add more comments now or help me update it or even add a log of someone else now if you want

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1MymtphqgUQQmlakk7BU4An3YHhd0LJIQqmlP3Py2oOQ/edit?usp=sharing

 

Alright, this is sure to get me killed, but I guess I'm already dead:

I am the cop. I'm gonna die in the second day and I'm the cop. That's why I've been overcompensating for my suspicion.
My first and ONLY investigation was al and he came off scot free.

I would've used tonight for Key or Mish but oh well.

 

GUYS, we need to change our votes to someone else who we have suspicions of. If this is correct, she will die tonight, if she is lying then we will lynch her tomorrow. If she doesn't die tonight but still turns out to be telling the truth, we get another read. If we keep our votes on her and she is telling the truth then we have lost two town members. By switching our votes we have a chance of killing a mafia member, possibly finding another read and if she turns out to be lying then she dies tomorrow.[DOUBLEPOST=1417033531][/DOUBLEPOST]Oh also I've done a log of all of Key's post, he really hasn't posted very much and well hasn't said very much in the posts he has.

 

Like you guys, I'm much less suspicious of Cat~ after she took the time to make that presentation, but allowing her to be lynched... doesn't completely sit well with me. I understand the reasons and part of me agrees, but it just feels like we would be letting a now likely town member die. Then by the next day we are down 2 more people. I don't know. For now we should take this time to investigate our higher reads.

For example, KeyToTruth. They throw out votes based on hunches which on the second day just seems a bit weird to me. Most of their posts are short and without much speculation or meaningful opinions. Also...

Here they unvote al because of others' reasoning, and then vote Cat~ because..it's what the majority are doing? Just seems very off to me. Why did they wagon? They could have just unvoted al and waited to vote when they have formed their own theory or opinion. They did eventually come around and give reason to voting for Cat~ here, but it makes me wonder why they didn't just state those reasons when they voted. Seems like they hopped on a wagon without thinking and this is their way of trying to validate it after the fact.

##Vote: KeyToTruth12

Also, if there any questions I'd be happy to answer them.[DOUBLEPOST=1417033708][/DOUBLEPOST]welp, i had my post written up in another page and didn't see Cat~'s until after posting

 

Because I feel getting a soft lynch on him would help to get some ore solid answers, I'm gonna go ahead and cast my vote

##Vote: KeyToTruth12

 

Like I've put in my log, I'm not completely convinced that key is Mafia but he's not that bigger help to town and this may get some answers out of him. So for now I'll consolidate the lynch to get it closer to having someone other than Cat to lynch.

##Vote: KeyToTruth12

 

Well that was a screw up on our part. Sorry Cat~. In that case...

##Unvote: Cat~
##Vote: KeyToTruth12

 

We don't know if Cat is actually the Cop. Not everyone is looking at the thread and she could be lying about her role. Then again if that happened it would seem like she was budding with Al, since she said he was scot free, and Cat isn't stupid. It'd be a poor Mafia move. Because of that, I'm leaning towards town. Right not I'm not going to change my vote until I see that a few more people have posted, but I'll change my vote to Key as well. Better to be safe then sorry.

 

Why am I always late to the party? Eh, whatever. does this make me less suspicious now?/shot

 

Hey, I've suggested a plan that we don't lynch her as if she is actually the cop she will likely die tonight. If she isn't killed in the night, then we can lynch her but we will have one more reading if she turns out to be telling the truth. Also Key, is currently on soft lynch, we don't really want to hard lynch him. At least not before he's had chance to speak. Instead your time would be better spent looking at other possible targets.


I'll say that in bold so people see it,
KEY IS AT SOFT LYNCH - please nobody else vote for him.

 

OH Sorry Midnight I didn't see your post :/

 

Okay, I might not be the most productive person.
To everyone, I have nothing to say, really. If you have any specific questions, ask them.
If I'll be lynched today, then so be it.

 

- Who are your top reads as Mafia and why?
- What are your thoughts on Cat claiming to be the cop?

 

Aw ****

If you are the cop, I'm really sorry, Cat! I believe that you are, because even if you weren't, I have a feeling the true cop would come forward and sacrifice their anonymity in order to guarantee the lynch on you. Damn, if only we had a protector role in this game!

That means that Al is either confirmed town or Godfather. I'm more inclined to believe town though.

I'd consolidate on Key if he weren't already at soft lynch.

 

Lazy Votal

• Cat~ - 3 (Mish, KeyToTruth12, Risky Biznu)
• KeyToTruth12 - 4 (Trigger, Cat~, Midnight Star, al215)

With 10 left alive, it takes 6 to lynch and 4 to soft-lynch. Day ends Thursday, November 27th, 12:00 ᴘ.ᴍ. (EST).

 

To everyone apologizing, please don't. I'm not upset. This game's all about reading people, and the signals I was giving off didn't exactly scream "I have nothing to hide."

Now since Key is at a soft lynch and is kinda just accepting his fate, I'm at least 90% sure he's mafia. He's not even fighting it because he knows his fate at this point. Even so, I'd like something from you, man. Midny's questions are plenty reasonable...

 

Mak, Cal never actually unvoted Cat~. She just said that she would eventually.

 

1. Calxiyn is not on either votal for Cat~.
2. She voted Cat~ and then unvoted her before I got to change votals.

 

Oh, okay. She said to me that she was still voted there, but okay. I assumed she knew where her votes were but apparently not.