Mafia [Mafia] Miami Haze ~ GAME OVER (MAFIA WINS)

He's not the only one acting suspicious right now. I'll see what everyone else has to say before I make a final decision.

 

I'd just like to mention that Cal has had some stuff going on generally so her activity the past few days was pretty limited. I can't say anything for Reno but I don't think it'd be fair to vote for her.

 

Yeah right nice try covering for your PARTNER IN CRIME THERE MAFIA GUY

 

Trying to throw suspicion onto me from you? That's very clever there MAFIA MAN

 

Spoiler: Remember People!

 

Well, this hopped from discussion to joking rather fast. XD

Anyway, I have some problems with this post:

You start off by saying that Makaze has the potential to be our greatest ally or greatest threat, which first off, had already been established. Then you say that you'll keep your vote for him because you'd rather not get a no-lynch, which makes sense, but doesn't explain why you picked Makaze for your anti-no-lynch vote. Considering that you admit he'd be our greatest asset if he were town, I would think you'd want to wait and give him a chance to show his true allegiance, instead of trying to get him out as soon as possible. Then your next statement just doesn't sit right with me. If we kill him and he's a Townie, it will eliminate guesswork later? Guesswork is the point of the game. If you had said anything else, if you had said something like "If we do end up lynching a Townie, at least we'll be able to take a look at the people who really had it in for him," or "even if we do end up lynching a Townie, at least we'll have something to go on with the stuff he was saying." But it will "eliminate guesswork?" That just... that absolutely rings with suspicion. And then you finish off by saying that even if we pull off the miracle of lynching a mafia member on day one, it doesn't help us because we'd just have a repeat of day one with only a little bit more to go on? If we pulled off the miracle of lynching mafia on day one, we'd have a greater head start then ever! Even if we just have a repeat day one, that's a first day with one less Mafiosa to worry about.

This is by far one of the more suspicious posts of the day, at least as far as I'm concerned. So:

Vote: defau[DOUBLEPOST=1408386371][/DOUBLEPOST]DOUBLE POST MERGER OF DEATH!!!

Don't know why it didn't finish what I'd typed. XD

Vote: default

What do you have to say in your defense?

 

Whoops coulda sworn I took that off

 

@ars nvoa, i have a question. Is the bulletproof vest transferable? Like if the member that had it thought a different member was for sure going down that night, cpuld they 'visit them' and give it to them for protection?

 

Nope!

 

I agree with Marushi. default's post is mighty suspicious. If we eliminated a Mafiosi on day one, the next day wouldn't just be a simple repeat; the game would be flipped on its head for us to get that lucky. I'll wait until he makes his case before I change my vote.

 

Okie dokie

 

The bulletproof vest is grated onto the user's soul.

 

Well, Mak has a strong personality and that could be used to influence us into bandwagoning pretty easily. Regardless of whether or not he intends to, that could screw us over pretty easily if he has us chasing ghosts. Also I don't have much reason to change my vote at this point, nobody else is really threatening quite as much as Mak is. Also, I was just explaining the situation, you're saying I should have said something with a different tone or different word choice. I'm not exactly a cryptobox here for you to decode. I'm just making my points, you're reading way to deeply into my post. And sure it is one less Mafiosa to worry about, but they're still a collective, and they could still drag it out for a long time if they're good, regardless if one member is gone or not.

 

( I MAY JUST END UP ADDING A RELEVANT SPN GIF TO EVERYTHING BECAUSE IT'S APPLICABLE )
ANYWAY
I can agree that some of rat's thoughts are mighty suspicious, especially considering that most all of day one is nothing but guesswork. Seriously, if there's even the slightest chance that Mak will be helpful, why vote for him now?? Especially when there's Reno, who hasn't said a word and would be a much safer target if you're trying to avoid drawing attention to yourself.

Okay, that's a fair point. But even so, if you want to avoid being led on a wild goose chase then don't listen to Mak? He's making good points so far, and you can disagree if you want, but he's still a potential asset to the townies as a whole. Trying to lynch him at the moment only makes you look bad.

Also, it's likely that if he's not mafia he'll be dead in the first couple nights anyway.

 

Ah, but see, we are all cryptoboxes here for the others to try and decode; that is the point of the game. Your reasoning that you find no one else more threatening than Makaze seems like a valid enough reason to me. That makes sense. However, especially on day one, word choice and tone are the only things with which we can judge; and perhaps I am reading too deeply, but my vote will remain for now. Instead of arguing your case, you just got defensive. If you are a Townie, then yeah, I'm just grasping at straws, and I apologize for coming down hard. XD

 

This statement rubs me the wrong way. You're stating the obvious. One Mafiosi out of the picture is better than none, and to knock one of them off on the first day is still a great victory for townies. You talk like a Mafiosi getting eliminated isn't something worth celebrating.

 

The only way he'd feel that way is he's the role that's neither town nor mafia, I can't remember it's name, but the one that wins if all other special roles are gone.

Idk, Default might just be being default though.

 

The Reporter? I think that was it... But anyway, this isn't necessarily true. You say that the only way he'd feel the death of a Mafiosa wasn't worth celebrating is if he's a third party role, but he'd still feel that way if he were Mafia.