Ok *sigh* 1. The stock is squished up so much that you can hardley see the meaning of the sig. 2. It looks like you made that sig in 2 minutes. Its seems that you did not take your time with your sig. 3. (Sorry if this is not polite) Its boring. Its a picture that you scailed and put text. Put some color and C4d's or something. Make it seem exciting. I give it a 3/10 Try to follow some tutorials to get started....... And also, did you make the first one? And what program did you use?
First of all, post your sig in your post rather than saying "it's the second one" or something of the sort. There's nothing to criticize since it's not really anything but a squished up screenshot.
It's too squished and looks like you made it in paint. The top one looks like it was ripped >_< Or someone made it FOR you....idk about that though. If it was ripped, then you're in trouble D: