Mudkip, name him derp and don't evolve him. Then level the crap outa him and destroy the Elite 4 with a derp.
So far I've got 2 of every starter being voted for with 6 people giving legit votes whit Rat just being Rat. Next one is the winner.
I do hear that Professor Oak is an incredibly strong Pokemon - I shall cast in my vote for that particular starter.
We have a winner. Since you were the person to choose after I requested a final pokemon I'll use Torchic. And since you told me what to name it you've given me a new idea for a thread.