Birth by Sleep I understand perfectly.....

This is my explanation... it would also explain WHY 'Xehanort' had no memory... because his memory had a form of it's own...

 

Yeah, I could see how that is possible as well. We are all coming up with some really good theories here. It will be exciting to see what actually the truth is.

 

Isn't BBS nine years before KH1, ten years before KH2?

I agree with you completely on all of this except the last part.

Why exactly couldn't he have a Heartless? If he was sorta like Riku Replica, then he would have a body, a soul, and his own heart, correct? So he'd be whole. If he was whole, then he could split into a Heartless and Nobody, even if he was a "clone." I don't really understand why he couldn't have a Heartless.
(It's probably something totally obvious I don't know 'cause I haven't played CoM....)

Other than that, I agree that it is Master Xehanort's (Baldy's) Apprentice. It just seems to fit, to me.

(Sorry if I just made an idiot of myself....)

 

I do agree with you there. Riku Replica obviously had enough strength of will, even though they kept calling him a puppet and all, to break out of what Namine did to him, even without his own memories, and to go after Marluxia. He obviously had a heart, whether or not they say it was 'artificial' or not. However, I don't really think the apprentice had no identity of his own prior to Master Xehanort using him, so I don't really buy the last theory that well. If anything, Master Xehanort may have tried to absorb his spirit and use him as Xeh's Heartless tried to use Riku by stealing his body in a way but I would think the apprentice had to be his own person at least at some point.

 

Yeah, I don't really like it either. I was just wondering if I was missing something.
I'm keeping it open as a possibility, though. I can't see anything disproving it, so I'll still consider it.

 

WOAH I DIDN'T KNOW TERRA WAS XEHANORT - more reasons to play

 

It's definitely not an absolute thing right now. We are just tossing around our thoughts on what is possible. He's one of the 'lucky candidates' right now.

 

I thought that Xehanort was, Master Xehanort, the guy from KH2: FM+, the bad guy kicking Terra, Aqua and Vens butts.

I don't know how Xehanort can be Terra then.

 

Would you be angry if in kh3 there is another Xehanort running around?
What if its a nun and she calls herself Sister Xehanort?

 

I'm nearly placing a serious bet here that 'Master Xehanort' shows up in KH3. Whether he's going to be the absolute final boss....or we find another 'Xehanort' or something odd like that remains to be seen. Sistah Xehanort...now that would be a cool twist.

 

ANOTHER Xehanort? I thought KH was made for kids! How are kids supposed to follow a million people named Xehanort? XD
Sister Xehanort... *imagining scary mental image*