Kingdom Hearts II Evidence of Roxas' Heart

Ok, I was playing KHII today and I watched one of the DiZ to Riku/Xehnoheart discussions and it was right after the scene of Kairi and Roxas communicating. And DiZ said Roxas' HEART was in contact with Kairi's!! DiZ is really careful with his words and wouldn't say something without meaning it. So I'm not totaly convinced but maybe this means that Roxas really does have his own heart! What do ya'll think?

 

Hey, yeah, I think you're right!!!!!! I never really thought about it.....

 

Yeah, I'm pretty sure it says in the secret Ansem reports (Tho its been a while since i read them) that because of the short time Sora was a heartless, Roxas does have a heart and can still feel emotions. Not 100% sure though.

 

Well, if Roxas still has a heart, why is he in Orginazation XIII??

 

Roxas is still a nobody.That is why he is in the organization.

P.S. That might be true about Roxas having a heart because even Axel said something about it.

 

I think I get it. Sora is Roxas's heart. Remember, during the conversation between Roxas and Kairi, Sora came in as well. I think by "Roxas's heart" he meant Sora. "So that, in turn effected Sora." He said that, too. I really think Sora is the "Roxas's heart" DiZ spoke of.

 

i dont think that Roxas has a hart not that DiZ said that he had.
(watching video to make sure)
you know that in the progress, all the memories of EVERYBODY connected to Sora are starting to come back. maybe when Roxas fell, he started to look inside him to "feel secure" (when you are in an event like that you do the same) but he damaged the data of Kairi.so that's why he was connected.
ama edit this post when i finish watching the clip.

EDIT:
ok... dead giveaway...
but why does the game, S.E. and almost everybody say that he is a Nobody.?

 

Yes, Roxas does have a heart, it's been proven. The first clue is DiZ's conversation, like you mentioned. The second is in Final Mix, when Roxas is talking to Axel, and Axel says, "You really do have a heart don't you?" and Roxas doesn't deny it. And, it's also been said that because Axel interracted with Sora before he died, Sora revived his heart. And the final is when Roxas merged with Sora, he definatly had a heart then.

 

Roxas didt deny it but didnt accepted....
aww i am confused!

 

Well, I know I'm not completely right...but I'm positive he has a heart! I read somewhere in an interview that he does have a heart.

 

Huh, interesting. I've never thought about it that way. But now that I do think about it, Roxas IS a Nobody, and not a Heartless, so it wouldn't be too farfetched to say that he has a heart, but his heart is empty and can't have emotions. Or something like that.

 

I believe that statement is the answer. Roxas is half of Sora right? So they are basically two halves to make a whole. So when you talk about Roxas's heart, you are talking about Sora's. So it doesn't matter whose name you use because they both are part of the same being. Same with all the Organization members. Make sense?

 

My Point

See Namine and Roxas are The only nobodys whose others are still human and have a heart. There Fore Roxases Heart is alive and in both of them cause soras not a heartless and the heart they are talking about in the series is a spiritual heart.

 

The reason, when Roxas is falling, he can be in contact with Kairi and Sora is because Kairi is part of Sora.

Remember?
KH1:

Sora literally HAS Kairi's heart.
Roxas is half of Sora's heart.

They basically all share one heart.

 

I think there's still a lot more to the whole nobody thing to be revealed. Since Namine and Roxas were born from Sora and Kairi's hearts, with Sora not only being the keyblade wielder and returning from a heartless so quickly, along with Kairi possessing a pure heart, they're already exceptional nobodies so it wouldn't surprise me if he did have his own heart. It still really bothers and confuses me on why Roxas was so necessary for Sora to regain his memories... If Roxas and Namine formed after Sora became a heartless, and if he had lost such an important part of himself shouldn't he have changed somehow or been weaker because of it? It just feels like there's something we haven't been told yet...

 

One thing I have to say that may schnap all the people who argue against.

If Roxas didn't have a convincing heart, wouldn't he have noticed it during his time in Twilight Town? In Riku's Epilogue in Re: CoM he smiles at the camera, indicating he is truely happy. If he had no heart, that would have been impossible.

 

He's a nobody he can't have a heart but may be your right. Also on Day one when Roxas falls over you hear DiZ say "His heart is returning. Doubtless he'll awaken very soon." or something like htat. Perhaps that has something to do with it.

 

Actually you guys, it seems pretty obvious.
Roxas has a heart.
But he shares it with Sora.
Half is Roxas.
Half is Sora.
Simple, neh?

 

im agreeing with u guys i think roxas has a heart for a few reasons

1.) sora turns into a heartless so thats wen roxas was formed

2.)sora comes back thanx to kairi so wen he came back he had a heart

with this evidence this proves that roxas has a heart because like i said before sora has a heart and roxas is still there so therefore roxas has part of soras heart sry if i made it confusing

 

roxas does have a heart

of course roxas has a heart, it says so in final mix +, also when he's in twilight town he shows lots of emotion, and nobodies can't feel emotion, he cant b fakin it either because he dosnt know he's a nobody...