Kingdom Hearts II Axel Bad or Good?

Overall i can't tell,is Axel a good guy or a bad guy? I mean his actions are good and bad so i can't really tell.The reason i'm asking is because,i have two albums:My Top Ten Bad-Guys,and My Top Ten Good-Guys.Well as you can see from this link http://www.kh-vids.net/album.php?albumid=2061&pictureid=19315 i sticked him in with the Bad-Guys,but where should he really go?......Again the question is,is Axel Bad or Good?

 

Axel, he's really just a good guy that made bad mistakes. Without a doubt, if he lived longer he would of quit the Organization.

 

We've yet to really know what his intentions have always been.
When he joined the Org with Saix, they seemed to have some type of plan together. And for some reason their friendship aswell as their plan faded away.
I believe he kind of didn't fight for good or bad in the end. I believe he just was looking out for himself. But when he met and became friends with Roxas, he starte dto look out for him like a little brother. In the end he died for his friend. He never liked to be on the black or white side of things, but stay in the middle, grey.

 

The Axel we know is a good guy. I want to know what made him lose his heart as Lea. That is what made him a bad guy. Axel realized that he ruined his chance at life and lost his heart. He joined the Organization because Saix also did. Saix was all that was left of Axel's previous life that he could confront without being called crazy. Axel probably wanted to feel like a real person again. This was made true when Axel told Roxas that Castle Oblivion changed him. He also told Sora that Roxas made him feel like he had a heart. Axel eventually kills himself just to ensure that the one who made him feel "real" again would be real.

 

I'd say that he's a good guy but like everyone else in the series he's made mistakes. I think Luxord summed it up best by calling him a cheater. Now that the Nobody has been destroyed hopefully Lea will get a second chance like it said in the 8th director's report.

 

For that to happen, Axel's heartless will also need to be destroyed, and we haven't seen it.

Also I'd say axel started as a bad guy in COM and in the begining of KH2 he was still bad but faced emotional struggles between orders and heart, then once Roxas' story ends and he defects, he becomes a good guy.

 

He's a good guy, with dual-intentions. By which I mean he can be good, and then be selfish.

I really hope they put Lea in a KH game.

 

Lea was confirmed for BBS, same with Saix's somebody.

 

i agree that he is good but went down some bad paths. any money that if axel would of even helped sora in some way if he lived.

 

I don't think Axel can be called good or bad. He's simply Axel, and he made good choices and bad choices, but his reasons were never bad, in the sense that they were evil. Axel was just trying to get what he wanted, like anybody else in the world.

 

I always thought he was a nice guy that just got influenced by his feelings a bit too much :s

 

Definitly good he always had a sorta good intention behind what he was doing and sacrificed himself for sora I think he should of had some rebirth cause everyone couldn't help but like him

 

Honestly, I think he just moved to the beat of his own drum, which was, at times, a different one from everyone elses. For the most part, he would help people just 'cause, but he wouldn't hesitate to get his hands dirty to complete the mission, if necessary. Over time, he changed the more he hung out with Roxas, especially after his ordeal in Castle Oblivion. When his time with Roxas was over, he got fed up, and did his own thing altogether.

 

He's good I believe. He did all those things just to be with a friend.

 

I think he's a good guy that got in with the wrong crowd. Organization XIII isn't really all that bad of a group. All they wanted were hearts.

 

I think of him really as a misguided good guy. I mean, he did belong to the wrong side, but he really was helping Roxas (and eventually Sora) out from the very beginning.

 

Depends.

I say depends. he aftyer all attempted a major yaoi but that failed so he decided to help sora because hes roxas and he knows that if he helps namine will shure make horny feelings! xD

 

Axel is neither good or bad. He does the things he does for his own reasons, even if they aren't selfish ones. For instance, he captured Kairi in order to bring Sora back, so he could in the end get Roxas back. That didn't work, so he helped Sora, to get back at Saix, and to possibly find Roxas again. He's one of the guys in the gray, like Riku. They make decisions to help themselves and other people, even if the decisions are made in bad places.

 

He's both... I guess... But more on the good side than on the bad. Because Axel is a very nice person. And he helped Sora quite a lot of times.

 

I don't thnk Axel was a bad guy. at first I didn't know what his intensions were. I thought he was evil cuz he was in the Org. at first. but, after seeing their side of the story, they didn't seem all that bad, and my opinion on Axel also changed. I think he had good intensions, especially when it came to Roxas and Xion. I dont know, that's just what I think.