Kingdom Hearts II Axel (and many other Org. III members)

Is it just me, or did they not do a good enough job with Axel, and him not having a heart? Because i think he seems to have one.

 

I'm not really for sure what you're asking but no he, like every other nobody, did not have a heart. Correct me if I'm wrong

 

I think she means that it seems like the Organization all had hearts.

And yes, most people here have noticed. ^^ According to Yen Sid, they were only pretending to have hearts.

 

I think that they did not have physical hearts, but they still had emotions of a sort.... or at the very least the memory of a heart was strong enough to create emotions. That's what I think Demyx was talking about when he was like "Oh, we do too have hearts! Don't be mad..."

 

Yes! Thank you, that is exactly what I'm talking about. Because Axel had a friendship with Roxas, and if he had no heart, then how would it be possible to feel such emotions of friendship? So their hearts must be strong enough to crate emotions, like you said. :)

 

I guess the way I think of it is that it's sort of instinctual to act like they have emotions. Because Saix said that they (the Organization) remembered what it was like to have hearts. So they're really just acting how they would have before they lost their heart.

 

Geez, I never got the point of the heart thing.
Did anyone ever look up "emotions" in the medical dictionary? It says that emotions come from the brain, not the heart. So, technically, the Organization can still feel emotions. They just don't have a heart, therefore, no blood circulation, and no point to breathe.
But, on topic.
Yeah, it does say (I think) that the Organization merely acts from their memories of emotions.

 

Good point there, ukali_rules.

 

lol nice. You sound like one of my friends. but yes very true that feelings come from the brain. Anyway KH is not real. So feelings can come from the heart. And in KH the hearts are not anatomically correct. So really there is no true answers. Just a bunch of evidence that leads you to both answers of him having a heart and not having a heart.

 

Well folks, I have my conclusion. There really isn't a true answer to this, but what you think depends on how you see it. Nice to see some of your openions :)

 

I agree there. Sometimes questions are made to not have an answer.

 

No, they don't have hearts or feelings.. they only pretend.

Or they delude themselves or something..

 

Hahaha, the Orginization deluding themselves- sounds about right! :P