Well, the colors and the effects are horrible, and is hard to see the render for the background that has the same color as the render.
I highly doubt it's as bad as you think it is... All it really needs is some sharpening and a photo filter (or selective color filter). Do that, and I don't really think it'll be that bad.
Meh, it does look quite blank...but it's not bad! (certainly better than something I could whip up...) I want to harness your skillz. D: 8.5/10
Misty, that is so cute. It does look like sharpening it would help, but aside from that I really like it.
It doesn't completely "phail", it just needs some better effects, a better background, and better blending. Then it won't be that bad. Basically just don't make your backgrounds so repetitive.