Or not. =/ The stock is a 2D render, so the background would look better in 2D. The stock also looks somewhat slapped on, the background would be better with less black. More like white, then add some black. The text is choppy, and not so pleasant, and the reflection of the text isn't nice either. Unless that isn't a reflection... Overall, 4/10 at best.
it is a 2d background. i just plastic wraped it to make it look like a mirror looking back at my friend.
No, the render is originally 2D. Plasticking it would make it worse. Find a 3D render of Tifa, then use it in a way like that. If you do use a 3D stock, get some C4Ds in there too.
Oooh. Good job! Although it's a bit too wide but you can fill in the Tifa in Advent Children in the center of the sig if you want to fill the gaps.