Missouri's right to pray amedment allows students to not do work because of beliefs.

Roaringflames · Aug 12, 2012

Missouri voters on Tuesday passed its "right to pray" amendment, reaffirming the right to pray in public and in schools.
In an effort to further define First Amendment rights, the measure formally known as Amendment 2 passed with 83 percent of the vote. The amendment's backers say it helps protect Missouri's Christians, about 80 percent of the population, who say they are public targets.

While the religious protections outlined in the measure are already guaranteed by the Bill of Rights and the Constitution, critics are drawing attention to another part of the amendment:
"No student shall be compelled to perform or participate in academic assignments or educational presentations that violate his or her religious beliefs."

The Missouri Constitution already allows people to worship according to personal beliefs, and prohibits discrimination based on religion for public office, testifying or serving on a jury, according to the Associated Press.
Republican state Rep. Mike McGhee, who introduced the measure, told Fox News that the section stems from a 2006 case, in which a Missouri State University class assignment was to write and sign a letter to the state legislature to support gay adoption.

But critics are skeptical. A New York Times editorial notes that the clause will "create confusion and wreak havoc in classrooms" by giving students the power to refuse completing or participating in any assignments that they claim violates their religious beliefs. It permits students who believe in creationism, for instance, to decline any assignments on evolution.

McGhee, however, says doesn't anticipate any instances where a student might claim "it's against my religion to do algebra."

The move in Missouri is in part seen as one of several pieces of state legislation nationwide that allows for more room for religion and intelligent design in public schools. The Tennessee state Senate passed a bill in March that protects teachers who allow student to question and criticize "controversial" scientific theories like evolution. Indiana legislators in January moved forward on a bill that would allow school districts to decide whether to include creationism alongside teachings of evolution in science curriculum.Oklahoma, New Hampshire and Missouri have also considered similar bills designed to encourage critical examination of evolution theory.

Research from two Pennsylvania State University professors revealed last year that the majority of public school biology teachers in the U.S. shy away from teaching evolution because they're either unwilling or unprepared to teach it: some advocate creationism while others are afraid to address the topic for fear of controversy.
According to results of the 2009 National Assessment of Educational Progress, a federal test known as the Nation's Report Card, less than half of U.S. fourth-, eighth- and 12-th grade students were considered proficient in science.
Click to expand...

Source:http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/08/08/missouri-right-to-pray-am_n_1757665.html

jafar · Aug 24, 2012

Well, this is just plain silly. Religious beliefs is a loophole that shouldn't be exposed, but they did it anyways. Huge mistake. I think there should be extended time if a person cannot complete an assignment because of religious requirements, but avoiding it entirely should not be an option.

Droid · Aug 24, 2012

Rainshine said: ↑

I think there should be extended time if a person cannot complete an assignment because of religious requirements, but avoiding it entirely should not be an option.
Click to expand...

I don't think that's the issue, although I guess it could be in some religions. The issues would be in the case stated in the OP where they had to sign and write letters to the state legislative on advocating gay adoption. Regardless of what anyone else's stance on that is(including my own, which is for it), the student's beliefs may be against that and they shouldn't be forced to do it. That would be same with any social issues, at the very least they should have the option to voice their counter opinion.
On the case of evolution vs creationism, no, religious beliefs shouldn't matter in that case. What they should do is teach an equal perspective on all the different ways life is thought to have started. Whether that be creationism, big bang, evolution, the mix between the two, etc.

Log in or Sign up

Missouri's right to pray amedment allows students to not do work because of beliefs.

Roaringflames Merlin's Housekeeper

jafar custom title

Premium

Droid Hollow Bastion Committee