Kingdom Hearts II I betcha Axel is just in disguise!!!!

In the scene with Axel and Roxas at the top of the tower, When Axel says: "See ya, Partner." he cries, and a tear falls. From the beginning, I always felt that Axel had a heart. I didn't exactly understand what Xemnas, Luxord, Saiix, and Xigbar were saying. About Axel putting something that didn't exist on the line, and awakening from getting too close to a heart. Please, do not misunderstand, I am not asking what the video means, I am asking if it is possible that Axel might have been a human in disguise as a nobody. Maybe a spy for Ansem? (The wise) I know his death is unusual, but Don't you think that he might have a heart? My friend and I both have the game, and have concidered the fact that Axel has a heart.


***************************************************************************************


"Got all that memorized?!"

 

He might have a heart, but then so would Demyx. I feel like this was posted before. Anyway Axel is dead. I'm sad but he is dead.

 

No, none of the Nobodies have hearts. Roxas doesn't. Axel doesn't.

Axel literally fades to nothingness when he dies, as do all the Nobodies. He also uses the portals freely like all the other Organization members.
And as stated in the games, the Nobodies remember their emotions and act based on that; they don't actually feel the emotion.

 

Roxas is special. Read the Secret Ansem Reports if you haven't already.

 

Axel said when he died that Roxas made him feel like he had a heart. So I guess being around Roxas lets him to feel emotions to an extent.

 

Yeah, you're right. But Even if he can remember emotion, i don't think remembrance in enough to literally make him cry.
And remember that Riku could also use the portals of darkness freely, because he had given into the darkness. Now Maybe Axel did the same. But then again, I think Roxas 13 is right. Alright guys. Thanks a million!!!!! :D

 

It still doesn't change the fact that he's a Nobody. You don't exactly have to have good intentions to have a heart. Saix displayed a sh*tload of RAAAAGGGE without a heart.

 

Axel, is a nobody, which means he doesn't have a heart. Roxas makes him feel like he has a heart because they have a relationship with each other as being best friends.
If Axel had a heart, then he wouldn't be part of the organization. In fact, he would be considered as a partner of Sora's.
Axel seems like he has a heart, but it's actually Roxas that makes him feel that way. Since Roxas is known as a traitor to the Organization for being the nobody of Sora's and his referred to "leaving", the Org. he was able to speak with Axel. When Roxas realized that Axel was actually a close friend of his and they became friends Axel felt as if he really did have a heart.
Hope that explains a few things.
Btw, I like your username :P.

 

For some reason, it's always annoyed me when they're like "NOBODIES DON'T HAVE FEELINGS RAWR!!!1!1one!"

I dunno. I know it's the way they established the plot, but something about it just really irks me and makes me not believe it.

 

Nobodies are only formed when someone gives their heart into the darkness, which makes the nobodies have no hearts.

 

I know. I just said that it really irked me, that plot point. *shrug* I'm one of those people who can't fake emotions, so I can't see how anyone could, ever. (Especially with the whole Axel and Roxas thing, how Roxas made Axel "feel like he had a heart". And besides, if they "wanted" to get hearts to become complete... how can they have a "want" if they have no feelings?)

 

I understand what you mean, but it is impossible for nobodies to have hearts. Even though Axel seemed like he had one, he only felt that way.

 

Also, Axel is gone. He faked it the first two times but then he didn't fad away, he went in those dark portals. He was my 2nd fav chracter. OHHHH WELL!

 

He is a nobody,he just began to fell emotions because he spent too much time with Roxas.
Roxas as some kind of heart yes,maybe not a complete heart or anything else,but if he didn't,he wouldn't fell rage/jeaslously for Sora when Axel died for him,or he wouldn't even have any kind of friendship with Hayner Pence and Olette,or even "love" or whatever it is with Naminé.
Axel spent too much time withRoxas,and deveoped some of these emotions too.
That's what i think.
That Roxas,a special nobody,a nobody that has feelings,made Axel,another nobody,develop them.

And if he felt.......
Yes,he was "making" a heart,his own,because of his bond with Roxas.
Otherwise,he wouldn't help Sora to go to TWTNW,and even Sacrifice for Him or Roxas.
If he put something on the line,he had something in first place.

 

I agree, I think Axel truly DOES have a heart. I mean, HE CARES!!!! :D Ain't it cute?

 

Well..it is quite impossible for Nobodies to have hearts.

But in Axels case he just felt that way because he spent too much time with Roxas. That's atleast in my opinion..

 

Maybe thats why the apparition of Roxas fought Sora, because Axel was destroyed. I don't want to say died because you die if you have a heart. Nobodies don't exist.

 

Yep,that's exactly why,and it wasn't a apparition,it was Roxas itself.