I will honestly say, this is the scariest face I've yet to see on any kind of show. Now excuse me while I post it so I'm not the only one with lingering nightmares.
I think I've seen enough of that from other shows...which is strange, because you would think that's scarier. Maybe I just don't find black eyes all that creepy........AH! That's what I remember it from. It's not that creepy because it makes me think of Koshaku Chono from Buso Renkin (I'm not even going to see if I spelled that right. My point is across)
Looks like Light Yagami if Death Note was animated with a brighter color palette and during the early/mid-2000's
I think I got used to his right away, and that always seems to make me laugh. It's more like he's trying to just make as many faces as he can....although Joey's creepy chin certainly is....creepy...
It's weird, but when I see that look on women in anime . . . I kind of like it. Also, that's not the creepiest face I've ever seen. Watch 'Mama' and let me know if you still think that face is the creepiest.