Digital Art Help me decide on a Siggy!

Ok, I followed a few tutorials and made 2 sigs. Help me decide on which one i should use!=]

 

Boath good but i have a question did you make those renders or did you get them from a site if you did can you tell me where cause i found a good one but not many Kh stuff on it

 

i like the top on best but thats my opinon.

 

I found those renders...

 

The first one is better, but you still need a little work.

 

I like what you did with the background on the first signature, it really made the difference from something random (I feel the 2nd sig was more random with the background, just one colour tends to be boring unless you use it to your advantage creatively) to something that is interesting. Though the front objects (Sora and the text) stands out too much - it's not in harmony with the background. If you let some of the colours from the background reflect on the front objects it should become even better.

I hope you don't mind me giving you suggestions, I'm aware some people don't want crits. ^^;

 

Yeah I say the top one is better. Is more creative then the other.

 

Which one are ya talking about?

 

Both. It was an example of what the frontground and what the background is. In this case Sora and the text is the frontground, but as mentioned they stand out too much.

I was mostly aiming for the first signature, but if you want to work more on your 2nd signature I stay by the same suggestion.