Kingdom Hearts II Good Idea!! Please speculate.

Okay, there has been a lot of the BHS' close appearance to Roxas. IT ISN"T HIM.

Here's my theory.

He looks a lot like Roxas, but he isn't. What if, When Sora was asleep, his heart was taken out, and temporarily put into Roxas?? That's why Axel said: Don't you have a heart?? hehe. And then, if the heart was taken, Sora kept his body. And a nobody (And maybe a heartless) was created. If he had another nobody, mightn't it look very similar to Roxas?? And then he was found by the E.S? Made a knight and so forth.

What do you think?? Another nobody??

 

Ok...a bit redundant, don't you think ? Yet another Nobody of Sora ?

What do you have to back that up, except for you intuition ? Because it looks to me your evidence is a bit incorrect : the scene where Axel asks Roxas if he has a heart takes place at the very end of Sora's sleep, when Roxas has already merged with him. Axel says he will soon not be able to communicate with Roxas' conscience as he does right now.

He asks the question because Roxas has always been a special Nobody : his original recovered from his Heartless state very quickly. It means that the heart of Roxas' original was not lost to darkness after all : they shared a bond, and Roxas probably felt like he had a heart from time to time. Which is why a bond of friendship was formed with Axel, and why Axel felt like he had a heart thanks to Roxas, because through his bond with Roxas he was bonded to Sora's heart.

When the scene you speak of occurs, Roxas is about to merge completely with Sora : it is the time when he is still completely himself and feels complete. The time when there is perfect balance between Sora's heart and Roxas' mind and self-awareness. At this time he is his own man, like before, and can be considered to have a heart.

So I don't think the boy knight (Ven) is a Nobody of Sora. Like I said, that would be redundant and there's not much that points to it : KH2 was about the Nobodies, I don't think the next game will.

 

I don't think that the boy knight is a Nobody of Sora, seriously.

Btw, we have that 'Discussion of Secret Ending' that I opened for theories so please post there in future, thanks.