In my opinion, this list is by far too vague. Why isn't LBP on this list, Bioshock, MGS4, Mario Galaxy? If you keep the list with just these, then my personal opinion would be SSBB. Overall however, probably Rock Band 2.
soz, didnt think of much, yet im overtired but i wasnt shure if MSG4 came otu this year or last year =/
That list has almost no games, as Destined kindly pointed out. On the list, I'd have to say Brawl, but No More Heroes is my personal favourite this year.
Definately SSBB. I don like a lot of songs on RB 1 and 2 and Guitar Hero, although I do like it's guitars and drums.
Why the **** are RB1 and Halo 3 on that list? Damn this thread had potential until I saw the list. Rock Band 2 is my choice for best of '08 on that list.
On that list? Rock Band 2. Rock Band 1 and Halo 3 came out in 2007, so they don't count. But my proper choice is Fallout 3.