Ohh I like :p Theyre both really well made,and everything seems to fit in right. I also love the text :3 V1s my fave,as the border on v2 kinda makes it look smaller or something... But really nice work :)
I can see your attempt to make your sig have effects, but instead of just haphazardly layering effect after effect, take a look at the flow of the image you are using and go from there. Also, maybe choose a more readable text so that it is easier to read. With that said, I like the first version better. I think the concept that you've set up and with some new techniques it'll be really good!
It looks great. Text is pretty and fits the theme you've got going on. BTW what's the name of the font so I can download it...?
The background of the tag is very chaotic in my opinion. The image you used doesn't look like it's very good quality either, it looks really blurry. It blends in with the background way too much in my opinion. The main thing that bothers me is the blurriness of the image you used.
Without mentioning anything the previous users have said, you have a case of what we like to call the "floating head syndrome" around here. This typically doesn't look very good, so try and use the whole stock and not just the head haha.