Hey, I've also got smash (though I'm not that good), um so if you want someone else to play against my friend code is 2595-1373-6238.
As only one more is needed to lynch, I will put up that vote if nobody else does before the deadline. For now I'm waiting to see if anybody else says anything.
I'm really really stuck right now, I'm happy everyone's been helpful and put up their top 5 but I'm struggling to make up my own mind with so much riding on this. I don't just want to follow blindly when I know that two people here are trying to deceive us. Ughhh. I have suspicions but I'm not completely sure on any of them and the pressure to get it right is making me reluctant to commit to anything even though I probably should. Okay so Hyuge I find a bit suspicious due to her acting slightly different? The thing with disregarding the entire thread prior to them joining really irked me and seemed odd as surely we want to use all the evidence available to us to work it out but I'm not sure that alone would be a Mafia thing. The no lynch thing was also strange and made me more doubtful of her. I think the reasons she put for their suspicions are valid ones even if I may not agree entirely though. (I don't think I worded that very well but I'm still unsure of myself here) And then there's Trigger who from what I can tell only posted once in day three (to defend himself) and he's currently posted once in the current day. His last post was helpful and appreciated, and I can really sympathise with being super busy because I am too but there is almost nothing to go on. He did post a bit in the first few days and was trying to help (though voting Spike past soft-lynch was a bit strange) so I'm not sure. If we weren't in a MyLo (Mislynch & Lose) situation, I would be for killing him but as we are, we could policy lynch then lose. I really don't think I'm being much help here, sorry!!! Also reminder, we don't have long to go, we really need to decide on a target. I should be around today so I can add my vote where it's needed.
Apologises, I hadn't accounted for how busy uni was going to get. It's the end of semester so I'm getting loads of assignments and stuff. (Had an experimental discussion today which went sooo badly. ;~;) I'm loving the big posts guys. I was scared since Mish and Tummer were half the posts yesterday that it was going to go dead. Anyway, this isn't going to be an enormous post unfortunately. I just know I really should contribute more. I'm planning on updating all my logs as soon as I get chance as I've fallen a bit behind with them. So thoughts on people: Cal - I'm not actually as convinced that she's town as the rest of you guys, I mean I'm not saying that she's Mafia and I have no case on her but for me she's more neutral. I simply wouldn't put her as confirmed town for me. This is probably more based on her older posts though when I read her log, I haven't had chance to go through her most recent posts in detail yet. Zelda - She's an interesting one, so for the first few days of this game I was quite suspicious of her, that might of reflected in my log and she was more than right to bring me up on how I phrased certain things in there. But since Cat died and it turned out she was town, I've been a lot less so considering a lot of the initial suspicion was due to her defending Cat and possibly 'buddying' with Cat. I still think they are quite unhelpful and not the greatest asset to the town (though they have improved) but not necessarily Mafia. ...yeah, this is turning into a long post and I have to go now. I'll post the rest later.
I wasn't expecting Mish to die but she was quite a helpful townie so I suppose it makes sense. Note, now the Godfather has been killed al215 is confirmed town. This leaves us with: Calxiyn Zelda Midnight Star Spike Luna (hyuge) Trigger (This was taken from the OP, all dead and al215 removed.)
Sorry for being quiet!!! Life kinda took over and I'm literally on for about a minute before I have to go again. I'm really sorry. I'll consolidate on Tummer if that might help, I'm not completely sure he's Mafia but right now I don't know who else to vote for and I want to help. ##Vote: Risky Biznu
Welcome to the game~ Also I apologise that we haven't lived up to your high standards but I refuse to believe that nothing can be found from the last 10 pages of this thread. It may not be pages of super amazing in depth analysis (half the people in this thread are new to the game) but there is plenty of room for Mafia to make mistakes/leave clues. Likewise, how do you know Cat's death gives us no information if you refuse to look for it, plenty of people went after her and she left us with a power point of her suspicions that we now know is not trying to deceive us. I apologise but I dislike how you disregarded everything. Anyway, I'm still working on my top reads as I dislike giving them without reasons but I'll get them to you shortly. To help make up my mind I added a post log for Mish as I was slightly suspecting her due to her being the main person to case Cat~ but looking at all her posts, she seems to have been more helpful, logical and active than I'd previously thought so I'm actually now leaning more towards Mish being town. Also thank you to whoever added a post log for Calxyin, that may be helpful. She's been less active than I realised as well as two out of three of her top reads for Mafia in the second day are now confirmed town and the third one is al who a lot of people are convinced is town. Hmm. Reminder to everyone about my log, it's there for everyone to use and I've set permissions so you can all edit it and add comments or update it if you want. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1MymtphqgUQQmlakk7BU4An3YHhd0LJIQqmlP3Py2oOQ/edit?usp=sharing
Damn, I didn't realise how close we were to being overrun. The kill was as expected, we now know Cat was telling the truth so now we can look back on her posts and presentation knowing she wasn't trying to deceive us. it may also be worth who was pushing for Cat's death but even that may not be decisive as some points made against her were very valid and there was a fair amount of bandwagonning. Regardless, I think it is worth taking a look back at that now knowing Cat is town. Today may be an interesting day.
You know technically panicking about being lynched is actually quite often a Mafia trait, the reverse of what you've said. As for town, it's supposed to be that it doesn't matter if you get lynched if it helps the town as you're going for a group win instead of an individual win whereas as there aren't many Mafia, it matters more if a Mafioso gets lynched. I mean that doesn't mean key isn't Mafia and I'm not sure that applies to our games as nearly all of us are beginners, it's more normal to panic when lynched regardless of alignment. So I'm not knocking your logic, it's just that I think technically it was meant to be the other way around.
Oh while you're here, I was wondering what your top reads were for Mafia now? I don't think you've actually said yet who you suspect so it would be interesting and helpful for you to post who you suspect most.
- Who are your top reads as Mafia and why? - What are your thoughts on Cat claiming to be the cop?
Hey, I've suggested a plan that we don't lynch her as if she is actually the cop she will likely die tonight. If she isn't killed in the night, then we can lynch her but we will have one more reading if she turns out to be telling the truth. Also Key, is currently on soft lynch, we don't really want to hard lynch him. At least not before he's had chance to speak. Instead your time would be better spent looking at other possible targets. I'll say that in bold so people see it, KEY IS AT SOFT LYNCH - please nobody else vote for him.
Like I've put in my log, I'm not completely convinced that key is Mafia but he's not that bigger help to town and this may get some answers out of him. So for now I'll consolidate the lynch to get it closer to having someone other than Cat to lynch. ##Vote: KeyToTruth12
GUYS, we need to change our votes to someone else who we have suspicions of. If this is correct, she will die tonight, if she is lying then we will lynch her tomorrow. If she doesn't die tonight but still turns out to be telling the truth, we get another read. If we keep our votes on her and she is telling the truth then we have lost two town members. By switching our votes we have a chance of killing a mafia member, possibly finding another read and if she turns out to be lying then she dies tomorrow.[DOUBLEPOST=1417033531][/DOUBLEPOST]Oh also I've done a log of all of Key's post, he really hasn't posted very much and well hasn't said very much in the posts he has.
Oh guys, I've changed the settings on my logs so that anybody can edit it. Obviously when I die, I can't add to it, but I've made it so that other people are able to update it if you so wish. Likewise you can add more comments now or help me update it or even add a log of someone else now if you want https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1MymtphqgUQQmlakk7BU4An3YHhd0LJIQqmlP3Py2oOQ/edit?usp=sharing
Even if you are going to die, we probably still should do most of that, as much as we can before night. We can help everyone the best we can while you're still alive to weigh in (maybe me too) meaning they can make a more informed decision tomorrow. @KeyToTruth12 What are your thoughts on everything? Who are your top reads? Your posts all tend to be very short and that's not doing you any favours, take a bit of time and put a bit of effort into your posts or you're at risk of being lynched. You're near the top of a lot of people's reads.
Loving the format and this was actually really good and useful, it's making me doubt that you are actually Mafia. However (I'm really sorry!!) with this now, I think it may be most useful to town to lynch you and find out your alignment. The thing is if you're had people go after you and you've cased your suspicions and we should have a lot to look at. However, what it all means depends entirely on your alignment. If you turn out town, we look at your pp knowing it was genuine and look at who went after you. If on the other hand, you turn out to be mafia, well then we look at who went after you/defended you and your pp in a completely different light. I'm really sorry but as it stands I think the most helpful thing you can do for town is die. I'm sorry!!!
If you click on share in the top right, it gives an option to create a shareable link, that's why people don't need to get a link from me. Also this is really appreciated.
...That middle point is actually a very good point. That would have caused you a lot more suspicion than you already had. I apologise. Regardless of your alignment, it wouldn't have been beneficial to say that earlier. Therefore not saying that earlier really shouldn't be used to prove you are mafia. *mutters incoherently at spell-check trying to tell me apologise should be spelled with a 'z'*
You realise tagging log isn't going to alert me, right? And that really wasn't obvious in your post, it may have been more helpful to say that earlier in the day as this is the first you've mentioned of doubts about her. No, not particularly.
