I used to use all sorts of decks. I was okay.
I used to duel in the Arena, but I don't anymore
It's just the fact that it's a duel that's going to matter. Again I haven't dueled in months so no matter who I was dueling I would want to practice.
Okay. Lemme know when you get it to happen please
---------- Dude you'll slaughter me...If you're running a Chaos Deck with BLS I'm dead... ---------- Is...is that pun on purpose? For your...
So have you gotten RVR to test?
Okay I've had some time to practice and I'm ready to duel whenever you are
Yes he does, how else would he tell him that he needs to tell future Snape to go back in time?
I just remembered that it's possible to gift songs on iTunes. So, I shall buy it for Jayn if it wins. NOW VOTE FOR IT OR I WILL EAT YOUR BABIES
I have no idea who Rogue is, I'm assuming that's an owl and you're suggesting a letter? Reading a message from yourself would still make you go insane...in fact even hearing an oral message said to be from "Future you" would probably make you go insane
Which is why I doubt anyone would give him a time turner That's another issue. The only way for that to work is for whoever sends the note back to to tell themselves to send the same note back, otherwise there are eternally two of that person. And a person can't directly tell himself anything because seeing yourself (And I'm sure reading a letter from yourself) would make you go insane
Exactly. Other than Harry saving himself nothing that Harry 2 and Hermione 2 did influenced the sequence of events of Harry 1 and Hermione 1 whatsoever.
Spoiler You can't walk barefoot across the kitchen tile In the morning you have to let your car on for a while. The radio won't stop playing those jingles and rhymes You know that it must be Christmas time. La la~~ The malls are packed, The toys are stacked, You need to shop, No time to stop, A festive card for mom and pop. The best feelings come out with a simple chime, You know that it must be Christmas time. La la~ You know you feel it in the air, The time to care, the time to share- -Is Peter gay? -Huh? -Over there. So grab a friend, And dance all in a line, 'Cause you know it must be Christmas time, La la~ The boys and girls are wishing (Wish wish wish) Santa would write them back (Back back back) They can't wait to go fishing inside his big red sack, His big red sack, Santa's got a huge sack! So, if you're feeling down or blue, Hey buddy I've got some good news for you Get that chin up and let that smile shine, 'Cause you know it must be Christmas- I know it must be Christmas- we all know that it's Christmas time! Christmas time! La la~ You know it must be Christmas time And I wasn't kidding, I'll send you a dollar in the mail to buy it on iTunes!
I guess you didn't get anything from the video...both of those situations create paradoxes! Someone goes back in time to warn Sirius. Then nothing happens to Sirius, so nobody goes back in time to send the warning. Exact same thing happens with Dumbledore.
Because as I explain in the video, it isn't easy to fix a problem while creating a perfect time loop. It would be pretty much impossible to save Fred this way, for example.
Vote for the Deck'd song or I will keel you :V
I'm aware of that but you have to remember that the movies are considerably different from the books and are in no way canon. Yes I suppose Dumbledore did make a bit of a gamble...but then again his entire Horcrux theory (For which he lost his life) was also a gamble until Harry confirmed it. I haven't re-read the book since I came up with the theory but I did re-read it just a month ago.
Maybe it's just the part of me that doesn't really like Harry speaking, but I HIGHLY doubt Harry is even able to comprehend the importance of a perfect time loop in the first place, or has any idea of the impact of what he's doing. I kind of imagine Harry casting the Patronus and Hermione furiously trying to stop him. This is Harry Potter we're talking about- one of the most rash and reckless characters I've ever seen, and I've seen a lot.
I kind of feel like it was her intention, but she didn't want us theorizing about Harry having two souls so early, which is why she created a timeline where we can't see the original course of events. I'm aware of the butterfly effect, as I say in the video it IS possible to change the course of time as with the book example (You create a timeline in which nobody buys the book), so obviously lots of things change- but that's okay because you secure a perfect time loop in the process. It was just the movie, so I ignore the rock throwing- that clearly proves that the movie used a closed timeline Harry was able to cast a Patronus because the realization that he'd done it before had given him the confidence to do it. As I say in the video I believe surviving a Dementor's kiss would give that kind of confidence. And that later, future Harry couldn't stand watching it happen to himself, which is why he intervened. And this is what I have a problem with. I guess it's just differences of opinion but I really hate closed timelines. The only point I'm trying to make with this video is that there doesn't need to be a closed timeline for the time travel to work- it's basically an excuse for me to think of it as a bendable time line
Thank you! I don't know if you're into HP, but what do you think of the theory?
